Overview of BilboBaggins

Recent Posts

Informing the world about your PhD?
B

I submitted details of my PhD topic to a couple of online websites to do with the wider research context. I explained the gap I was filling, but was incredibly vague about the methodology and sources that I was using. So people couldn't steal my research, but knew that I was working in that area, and that was important to me not to be overtaken/gazumped.

I adopted a similar approach at conferences. When speaking to people I would be very vague generally, unless I was sure they were trustable.

I also was very vague about my sources and methodology when talking to a PhD student working on a similar area. Again so he could not copy what I was doing.

Couple of months in - too early to decide?
B

Quote From chococake:

I am very impressed! Have you had to change your literature review much? Or nothing at all? I think I want to take the ruthless approach and focus one way.


I had to change virtually nothing at all over the 6 years of the part-time PhD. A full-time student at a nearby university completed his closely-related PhD while I was doing mine, so that needed acknowledging and dealing with. But that was about the only change, and could be done in a couple of sentences out of a 7,000 word intro/lit review chapter.

Couple of months in - too early to decide?
B

Barring big problems with writing up (like finding you find it extremely difficult) 1 year should be enough. But you will give yourself a head-start if you can start writing up before then. Write as you go along. I sort of did this. But I wish I'd done it more.

Couple of months in - too early to decide?
B

Quote From chococake:

Quote From BilboBaggins:

I wrote my literature review (which remained largely unchanged by the end of my PhD) within 3 months of starting


Wow that is really impressive, how did you manage that?


Got on with it, and focused very quickly on the core literature. I was really ruthless. I didn't bother about stuff that was interesting but of marginal interest. I focused quickly on what I needed to, given my research interests, and was therefore able to write the literature survey fast.

And it's not as if I'd done any preparation beforehand. My PhD was on a totally different topic from my Masters - even a different century :p

the truth about journal submission?
B

Surely it isn't that expensive to post copies using the Royal Mail? I send things overseas for eBay all the time. It's not that expensive at all. If they are the best journals you should aim for them.

You don't need to send it by courier or anything like that. Just normal post. Preferably airmail, but surface mail if need be. And it will qualify for printed papers rate.

Couple of months in - too early to decide?
B

I was a 6-year part-time student. However I hit the ground running. I wrote my literature review (which remained largely unchanged by the end of my PhD) within 3 months of starting. Then I immediately started the research phase of my research.

I still took nearly 6 years to submit (which is equivalent to 3 years full-time), partly because I found the writing up hard, partly because my neurological disease progressed. In the final years of my PhD had no more than 5 hours total (in 1 hour chunks spread throughout the week) for study time. But I finished.

I don't believe you need to spend ages "finding your area" in the first year. I also think people can often waste a lot of time doing far too much reading/lit review, which isn't relevant later. And then people run out of time and run into the fourth year.

Finished PhD but still unemployed
B

If you seriously are suicidal please get professional help. Your GP is there for you, as are the counsellors at your university. And the Samaritans can be contacted at any time.

Have you taken full advantage of the careers service at your university? They may be able to suggest areas of work that you had not thought of.

Also what about the possibility of creating your own job and being self-employed Would consultancy in any form be an option? I don't know what your PhD is in, but it's often an option.

Good luck!

the truth about journal submission?
B

I'm with you Sneaks. I'm expecting a decision in the next couple of days (by end of this week the editor said). It's rather put me off checking my email to be honest!

the truth about journal submission?
B

Wow I envy you lot with whizzy online systems you can check to see the status.

I'm a historian, and although this is a very high impact journal I've aimed for, it's still a case of emailing the people and asking about status. No whizzy computer systems.

And even that only works if they reply to your email. I first asked a month ago. No reply. Then I emailed again yesterday.

the truth about journal submission?
B

I've had papers accepted. I think the wait-forever-equals-rejection is a myth.

Though I hope not. I've had a paper with reviewers/editors for 7 months (!). This is a journal that advertises its usual review time is 3 months. I emailed the editors to check its status this week. They are going to decide by the end of the week ... :$

Just about to submit thesis and want to thank....
B

Delighted to hear you're reaching the finishing line. And glad my advice was helpful.

Best wishes for the future.

Its time
B

Good luck Sneaks. Sounds as though you've done a lot of the groundwork already though, in terms of existing drafts. So while redrafting is hard (for example cutting down your lit review to an acceptable length) it's better than starting from scratch. So you should get there ;-)

First Class at BA, potential 2:2 at MA
B

Quote From bow:

I didn't do a masters degree so i could be wrong but don't masters degrees use a different grading system to bachelors degrees (distinction, merit etc).


Yes that's right. I've never heard of a postgraduate Masters with a bachelors-style grading system. The original poster needs to check on this. Normally Masters are pass, pass with merit, or pass with distinction. The grades needed to achieve the different levels vary by university.

Slowly Sinking
B

I would also recommend considering seeing the university chaplain, even if you are (like me) agnostic, or an atheist. They can relate really well to very serious health situations, and would be very understanding about what you've been going through with your daughter and trying to juggle a PhD as well.

I went to see my chaplain in 2007, after my consultant had said there were virtually no options left to try to battle my life-threatening (and used to always kill) progressive neurological disease. I tried the university counsellors first, but they couldn't understand the severity of what I was dealing with. But the chaplain was great. And because she had a PhD as well she could relate well to that side.

Good luck!

Census
B

I was a bit disappointed by that too, when we filled in the census online on Sunday night. My hubby has a PhD too, so it's not so much competition in our house on the academic front. Though I did tick more qualifications boxes than him, mainly because I have a SCOTVEC certificate in interfaces and control systems (robots and traffic lights - I'm really good at designing traffic lights)!