Overview of HazyJane

Recent Posts

Please recommend good books on the PhD and Research process
H

BTW Fled, I'd not come across that blog you posted before - it's really really good! Thanks for sharing it.

Please recommend good books on the PhD and Research process
H

On the website front, I'd also recommend Thesis Whisperer:


Seeking advice
H

Ask whether there would be the opportunity for the MPhil to be extended into a PhD if your progress was satisfactory (rather than having to start over). If so then your situation would not differ markedly from students at unis where one is required to 'upgrade' after a year or so.

Is the availability of funding influencing your potential supervisor's advice (e.g. is it just that there isn't money for a full PhD?)

Moving from a Russell Group to Ex-Poly
H

Quote From Fled:
Not sure I am convinced about the "If it's free, its always better" argument.


That's not really the argument I was putting forwards.

Obviously any funded offer still needs to be critically evaluated. But I think the risks associated with an unfunded PhD are not (for most people) worth it. As Ian says, the direct cost of doing a full time unfunded PhD in the UK is around £50,000 in fees and living expenses. But there are also indirect/opportunity costs. By doing the PhD full time, you prevent yourself from obtaining a paid full time job, which would probably pay you at least £15,000 a year. So if you factor in that too, you're looking at an 'investment' of around £100,000 into a qualification that has a low chance of guaranteeing the desired career path subsequently. For most people that would not be a smart investment.

So, if given an unfunded offer, I would only take it up if I could secure external funds (e.g. from charitable trusts) or do the PhD part time so as to (i) have an income and (ii) get employment history for my CV to fall back on if the academic career doesn't work out.

Good luck with your decision.

Q: Starting PhD shortly; dedicated study at home worth it?
H

Have you asked your wife's opinion?

If you're going to be working at home most of the time, I would encourage doing what you can to establish work-life separation. Having a dedicated study performs two functions - firstly giving you some 'do not disturb, I'm at work' space. But also, when you're not working, you can physically leave your stuff (and hopefully stresses) there and rejoin your family.

PhDs tend to be a bit all consuming, so anything that helps you stay rooted in reality would be likely to be beneficial.

How to find the balance between funding opportunities and school rankings?
H

I've said elsewhere that I would caution against doing a full time PhD unfunded as the employment opportunities at the other end are slim, so it can be a dubious investment of personal resources.

However, it depends on whether your post PhD plans are academia or something else. That will affect the decision you need to make.

Strange behavior from my previous boss
H

Quote From SarahReed:
Maybe he does not want to see you succeed, you know what I am saying. Or, yeah, could be that he is lazy, but I think that he wouldn't like to see you get a stronghold in your career path.


I think administrative reluctance/incompetance is a more likely explanation than outright malice.

Working post-submission / pre-defending - tax etc?
H

Sorry, my wording was ambiguous - the other two are both right.

Basically you continue to be a student from the university's point of view until your PhD is properly viva-d and signed off.

You cease to be a student from a tax point of view when you commence a full time job.

I see no reason why the latter requires you to formally de-register.

Academic references nightmare?
H

And if that doesn't work, contact their PAs/department admins. They're usually pretty good at sorting these things out

Moving from a Russell Group to Ex-Poly
H

Quote From bewildered:
Depending on your field, strong research methods training might be important, so you might want to compare what both institutions have on offer


Definitely. And also the likely availability of the respective supervisors. The supervisor can make or break the project.

Moving from a Russell Group to Ex-Poly
H

Hard to comment without knowing the institutions and subjects but...

- depends on your long term aims and the field you are in. In some fields the academic career prospects are dire regardless of where you've studied.
- that said, a 'good' uni may boost your credentials.
- at research level, sometimes it's the PI/department reputation that matters more than the university, so do your homework on this front.
- generally I would caution against anyone doing a full time unfunded PhD *anywhere* (even Oxbridge), but others will disagree with me on this. This applies particularly, in my opinion, to anyone wanting to pursue an academic career, as the chances of the 'investment' paying off are so slim.
- depending on what you're doing, it can be good to mix it up and not do all three of your degrees at the same university.

Working post-submission / pre-defending - tax etc?
H

I'm not sure, but I would have thought you do not cease to be a student until you've defended and any corrections are signed off, so would have to say registered until then. There is nothing stopping you from working in the mean time, but some HR department will need to assign you a tax code.

I don't think you need to have been 'discharged' from your current uni in order to get a tax code. After all, people have part time jobs and study full time, or vice versa, so the two statuses are not mutually exclusive.

FGD Masters
H

As I asked on your other thread....what does FGD stand for?

We can't help you if we don't know what you're asking! :)

Discussion after PhD interview
H

Yes, that sounds like a good idea. Just ask whether there is anything you're supposed to do, or whether you should just wait to hear from them.

PhD Problems
H

Do you know why people left? If it is because their projects ended and moved on that is less of a concern than if there is something like bullying/poor management going on.

As TreeofLife says, there are various ways to get funding to apply to conferences. Either through charitable trusts. university grants, or from the conference organisers (e.g. if you want to go to the annual conference of an academic society, join them as a student member and you may be eligible for a subsidised place or a grant.)

Conferences are helpful for meeting people and to get the opportunity to present and discuss your work. But it is not the biggest problem in the world if currently you cannot attend one. You just have to get creative. There are other ways to network, such as online (e.g. lots of academics use Twitter to connect). And if you want to present your work outside your institution, make contacts with other universities that might host a talk from you and try to organise it to coincide with other travel plans e.g. if your home town/country is elsewhere, consider giving a talk nearby next time you visit.