Overview of HazyJane

Recent Posts

Looking for research topics around Cloud and Big Data
H

Have you identified a potential supervisor/research institution? It might be helpful to develop the proposal in consultation with a supervisor who can guide you as to what kind of level of content/detail is required for a PhD. It might also be worth looking at pre-funded adverstised PhDs; I imagine there would be a far number in this growing area.

Can I get my independent research recognised as a PhD
H

[Part 2]
Though you will have undoubtedly acquired relevant research skills outside of academia, there are other benefits to affiliation with a university that you might regret lack of access to, especially if you aim to forge an academic career. A good supervisor/department will give you access to a network of other people in the field - and their name on your papers might get your work noticed by a wider audience. There may be free training on offer on various aspects of academic research, or travel awards for attending conferences. The support from other students you might find in a good department can be valuable. Internal peer review processes can save you a lot of wasted time when it comes to submitting research to journals. It may also give you a realistic view of the job prospects in your field - it isn't always easy to pick up on this from outside.

I have nothing against the concept of PhD by publication, but it's usually for people who have already been in academia for a long time and notched up a solid body of peer reviewed work. It's far less typical for people to plan to go down that route when the work has yet to be published. I just wonder whether you would be making things unnecessarily complicated for yourself by taking this path, when a more conventional route (albeit part time) might serve your aims just as well.

Can I get my independent research recognised as a PhD
H

[Part 1]
I'd strongly suggest getting advice from a relevant university department/senior academic before proceeding any further. Although it is possible in some cases to be awarded a PhD based on retrospective work ('PhD by publication' - see: http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/416988.article) I gather in most cases these are only awarded to people who are existing staff/students of an institution i.e. you can't just approach a university to which you have no affiliation and ask to be assessed for a PhD by that route. Some examples of university regulations here:

http://www.sheffield.ac.uk/ris/pgr-support/phdbypublication
http://www.york.ac.uk/about/organisation/governance/governance-documents/ordinances-and-regulations/regulation-2/#2.9
http://documents.manchester.ac.uk/display.aspx?DocID=7422

Is there anything standing in the way of you approaching a potential supervisor at a relevant department and asking to do a part time PhD there, maintaining your current job and co-supervision from your manager? If the fees are a deterrent, consider it's likely that even the PhD by publication route will incur fees, and set requirements of written material beyond just the papers.

Stata help ££
H

There are quite a few Stata courses at unis e.g.


/
Stata also do online net courses which are cheaper than face to face training.

education issues our nation is facing
H

Are you asking us to do your homework for you?

I would suggest using a search engine in the first instance to identify educational issues or sources of information in the relevant country, before moving on to searches of more scholarly resources. Ask your university librarian for advice on search strategies if you're unsure.

Alternatively ask the person who set the essay question for some pointers to resources.

is getting a tutor acceptable?
H

I'd recommend talking to your dissertation supervisor in the first instance. If you seek external help, you may be lead off in the wrong direction. Really, any training you received during the course should be adequate for your dissertation - it may be that you're planning something too ambitious for the course requirements. The dissertation can just be a means to an end.

It's better to do something simply, but carry it out and write it up really well, than try something overly complex and not have time to meet all of the criteria on which you will actually be marked.

Courses for short time
H

If you're just looking to learn/pass the time without any specific training goals, may I suggest checking out free online course providers such as Coursera, EdX or Khan Academy?

Another job app rejection letter
H

Quote From satchi:


I did write about it in my personal statement--and the interviewer asked me again!
So I found myself saying the same things :-(

It's not uncommon for interviewers to ask questions that were already on the application form. But you should maybe interpret this as indicating that they wanted a more in depth answer from you in person - to expand upon what you had said on the form.

Quote From satchi:

There was a research position advertisement (deadline ended 23/6) which I was going to apply for, but then there were 3 application questions--one of them was how you communicate with colleagues at work--and another was something like--name a different method of communication which you used to influence people---and I found that I couldn't answer them!


It might be a good idea to go away and reflect on these questions to come up with answers. They are the sort of generic skills questions that might be asked in an interview for ANY kind of job. If you come up with answers now then you will be ready for future applications if they come up. It is a shame to let a job advert pass because of something generic like that.

Are you still in touch with a university that has a career's service you can access? It might be worth making an appointment so they can help you do a skills inventory and reflect on questions like that.

Another job app rejection letter
H

Quote From satchi:
hi Elsie and JanineG
thanks very much for your replies
what is the best way to answer this question then. The interviewer says, "I see you have different qualifications. Can you tell us about it?" or "I'm curious to know why and how you have these qualifications"

Twice I have told them the truth, that at first I did Geographical sciecnes and then I realised I was interested in studying people. It seemed like telling them my life story, I didn't tailor the answer to the skills because the skills I felt came later.

How can I improve answering this question?

Personally I wouldn't wait until the interview to answer this. I would address this, at least briefly, in a covering letter/personal statement. At the end of the day, it doesn't matter so much *why* you have studied two areas, so much as what those studies enable you to bring to the table now. If you can show that X built on Y then it helps. It doesn't matter what your motive for transition at the time were - what matters more is how those different perspectives enrich your current understanding of the world. As Elsie suggests, if your undergrad degree involved any human geography, that could be a useful segue between the two areas.

Looking for new PhD after previous horrible experience
H

I quit a PhD and started another, but I was no where near as far through the process as you. I'd suggest just getting it finished, letting go on the 'corresponding author' issue (it's REALLY not worth making a big issue out if it - there will be other papers), getting it finished as soon as possible, and moving on to somewhere better. As long as you are the first author on your papers, having him as last author need not detract.

The bit that does raise some concerns is that your supervisor was trying to manipulate the data to imply that the experiments were working. This sounds like potential research fraud, which is a very serious issue. Don't get sucked into it. Make sure that any results in your papers and thesis reflect true results of experiments, or else it could have negative consequences for your career.

Just heard back about the feedback for the PhD application, help needed!!
H

Quote From JanineG:


I feel stuck as my course was closed in the honours year. So what can I do?


I recall you posting about your problem of the university not issuing honours for class group for some administrative reason. It really is a very unusual situation that most academics will not have come across. For future applications I would therefore recommend if possible enclosing some kind of official letter from that uni explaining the situation. That might carry more weight than your explanation of the situation alone.

When to start applying for ethical approval?
H

Estimate how long you think it will take you to get ethical approval. Now double that, and add six weeks.

That might sound OTT, but it really can be a painful process. Even 'low risk studies' can be a palava. Not the actual approval by the committee bit - that can be quite straightforward - but rather all the steps you need to do to get to that stage.

Are you applying to an internal ethics committee, or an external one? The latter will probably take longer as it might need to be reviewed and signed off by various people before it goes out.

So I would definitely get started now, even if you don't know all the details yet. It can actually help you organise your thoughts about your proposal. At the very least, identify all the relevant departmental/institutional signatories you will need to get to look at your form, and see if there is any general advice at your uni about ethics applications.

I think my supervisor is disappointed in me
H

Did you explain to him why you cancelled?

One option might be to take the initiative to propose a new meeting date and state what work you intend to have finished by then. It will also give you a target to aim for.

Ever felt completely and utterly out of your depth?
H
Ever felt completely and utterly out of your depth?
H

Ever feel out of my depth? Frequently! :-) (3rd year student, several years research experience).

In general it should be fine to discuss these things with your supervisor, but if you're feeling uncomfortable, is there a graduate tutor in the faculty? Or even a helpful post doc? Sometimes it just helps to have a chat with someone local.

Regarding training, if you can find an external course that you think would really benefit you, there may be ways of funding it from departmental/faculty funds, or even charitable organisations. If you know what you want to learn, but haven't found an appropriate training course, ask here or in a new thread and people might be able to point you in the right direction.

Finally, I always find this a reassuring read when I feel out of my depth: