Quote From tt_dan:
I'm asking this in a general sense; does it look bad for the supervisor if the PG student, especially the PhD student drops out from the programme?
Dropping out reasons I can think of at the moment are:
1)No funds
2)Poor supervision/No direction
3)Personal issues
4)Supervision conflict
Yes. The supervisor may look bad for poor supervision. But PhD student does not look good too; a quitter. This PhD student did not choose supervisor carefully!
2) Poor supervision/No direction is not necessarily bad. PhD student should be independent!
3) Personal issues are common everywhere. We are all "wired" differently.
4) Supervision conflict: If the supervisor is very brilliant, then the student could be perceived as incapable and wasting the professor's time. If the student is more brilliant, then the supervisor could be perceived as useless. Moreover, supervisor and student may not be compatible in terms of thinking style. For example, men from Mars, and women from Venus.
My supervisor is quite weak. Luckily, my external examiners have good comments on my thesis. However, this thesis could have reached greater heights.
One suggestion is to ask other PhD students within the university about your supervisor. Just to make sure you are not biased.