Overview of MeaninginLife

Recent Posts

Has anyone done a video presentation for a conference?
M

Some postgraduates attended the conference free by doing "volunteering work'.
For accommodation, go for the cheapest, say one or two nights which should not cost much.

There should be department fund etc for postgraduates in attending conferences.
Last resort, borrow money from your supervisor for air ticket...

Has anyone done a video presentation for a conference?
M

Video presentation was allowed in some Japan conferences.
Perhaps there were worries about earthquake, tsunami, radiation...
Moreover, accommodations and food may be more expensive.

Yes. BilboBaggins is absolutely right that some professors may provide better or more feedback than your supervisor!

Has anyone done a video presentation for a conference?
M

You may want to re-think this question.

1. When we present papers in conference, we may get new perspectives or feedback on our work.
2. It is good opportunity to attend conference and make new friends or even "find" future job opportunities; or potential examiners...
3. Enjoy the local attractions and food... shopping... relax... new ideas...

Supervisor badmouthing me - help
M

As mentioned earlier, we should seek first to understand, then to be understood.

There are a few things we do not know about worldaround...
1. Which year is worldaround in?
2. There is nothing wrong for first supervisor to ask for meeting in her office. From the viewpoint of supervisor, it may seem strange why meetings have been through Skype.
3. Actually, secondary supervisor could be correct to say that first supervisor is busy, and thus behaving like that. Supervisors also have their stress nowadays over funding, publications, admin...

So, worldaround could also let us know if the supervisor has been "misbehaved" for months or years.
My main point is don't over-react. It could get worse!

In fact, from now on, i feel that there should be meeting with both supervisors for the moment.

Supervisor badmouthing me - help
M

Quote From WorldAround:


I've raised the matter with the secondary supervisor and according to him, the first supervisor is busy so that's why she's behaving like that.
It seems from here that he's more interested to protect her well being (theirs?) instead of mine.
: (


But you also badmouthing your first supervisor by raising the matter...
In a sense, you also badmouth your secondary supervisor.

Perhaps seek first to understand, then to be understood.
Be cheerful! Don't get trapped in defending...
By defending yourself, some may suspect you're feeling guilty...

Your first conference
M

I was sick during my first conference.
I was also worried if very few attended my presentation and some professors might pose difficult questions...
Fortunately, there were at least 10 participants, and only one difficult question was posed by a professor. I did not pretend to know the answer but simply explained that there should be more research...

This professor was a journal editor and suggested me to reorganize my conference paper, and submit it to his journal.
He also gave me some advice privately after the presentation and my paper was published shortly.

In my last presentation, the room was full and it seemed well received.
However, i don't feel anything special with conference now.
It is a place for networking. The participants are more concerned of their own presentations.
Why allocate memory space for the presentations of others?

The participants rather remember your kind words or feedback on their presentations.

What other skills do I have (in case something happen to the PhD)
M

It is a waste to quit if there is paper published and conference papers accepted in second year.
Perhaps it is better to have no backup plan.
Conflict with supervisor is not uncommon.

What other skills do I have (in case something happen to the PhD)
M

Something like this...

WRONG WAY:
PhD student: “I am a nuclear physicist.”
Employer: “Oh. We’ll call you.” (Won’t call you...)

RIGHT WAY:
PhD student: “I can read schematics and troubleshoot electronics. I can make machine drawings using CAD programs and perform statistical analysis on large quantities of data. I’m not afraid to disassemble instruments to fix them or to think hard. I did all these things as part of my graduate training in physics.”
Employer: “You’re hired! By the way, why did a smart young person like you study an obscure topic like physics?”

Does it look bad for the supervisor if the PG student drops out from the programme?
M

Quote From tt_dan:
I'm asking this in a general sense; does it look bad for the supervisor if the PG student, especially the PhD student drops out from the programme?

Dropping out reasons I can think of at the moment are:
1)No funds
2)Poor supervision/No direction
3)Personal issues
4)Supervision conflict


Yes. The supervisor may look bad for poor supervision. But PhD student does not look good too; a quitter. This PhD student did not choose supervisor carefully!

2) Poor supervision/No direction is not necessarily bad. PhD student should be independent!

3) Personal issues are common everywhere. We are all "wired" differently.

4) Supervision conflict: If the supervisor is very brilliant, then the student could be perceived as incapable and wasting the professor's time. If the student is more brilliant, then the supervisor could be perceived as useless. Moreover, supervisor and student may not be compatible in terms of thinking style. For example, men from Mars, and women from Venus.

My supervisor is quite weak. Luckily, my external examiners have good comments on my thesis. However, this thesis could have reached greater heights.

One suggestion is to ask other PhD students within the university about your supervisor. Just to make sure you are not biased.

How do you tell your supervisor that you're unhappy with their supervision?
M

On second thought, we should be thankful of supervisors who are not very demanding, does not bully us, and give us more freedom in our research.

The only concern is supervisor's recommendation letter should be carefully written. It should not be accidentally suggestive or saying the student is unhappy with one's supervision...

How do you tell your supervisor that you're unhappy with their supervision?
M

Sound like my supervisor. Actually, I also need advice on this...
She insisted to be the corresponding author for my paper which is fine.
But she submitted earlier version of my paper instead. This is so dangerous. :-(

However, she is better in presentation. So, it may not be easy to detect her weaknesses like organisation... Beside, my supervisor has some strengths such as EQ...
When my thesis was submitted, she "protected" herself by explaining to the examiner etc... that the thesis may not be ready.... But she was just doing a favour for me since I am confident of my work.

Essentially, if the thesis has minor corrections, she can claim some credits. But if the thesis has major flaws, she is already aware...

Maybe just let your supervisor know about similar websites like postgraduate forum.

Sooo many things to edit and check!
M

one of my papers has nine pages of references; i was enjoying movies at the same time... :)

Publications: which one is not the best situation?
M

Better still, it depends on the co-authors: Nobel laureate, Field medalist, Director, Head of Department...
Or many different groups of researchers; it shows that you can work with anyone.

Publications: which one is not the best situation?
M

You should really focus on the quality of your papers.

Anyway, impact factor is also very important. Below are some examples...
1. Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics (JCAM) (ISI impact factor: 1.048 (2008), 5-Year Impact Factor: 1.138)
2. Computers and Mathematics with Applications (CMA) (ISI impact factor: 0.997 (2008), 5-Year Impact Factor: 1.049)
3. Applied Mathematics and Computation (AMC) (ISI impact factor: 0.961 (2008), 5-Year Impact Factor: 1.124)

Quitting?
M

Perhaps you could discuss with your supervisor on certain concepts first? Let him know you have difficulty understanding certain aspects?
Then, ask your supervisor about his expectation of PhD research?

...... Finally, discuss your difficulty... (But don't reveal you have decided to quit yet!!!)
Perhaps you can also ask you supervisor to share his feeling about your progress.

When breaking news break too fast..., it can be truly heart-breaking.