Overview of Barramack

Recent Posts

PhD Tenses
B

This is a good article from the University of Melbourne about using tense in scientific writing. It has helped me to get my head around the correct use of tense.


Thesis vs. depression
B

It's going to be a challenge if you haven't started your data analysis yet. That stage usually takes the most time. You don't have the luxury of trying out different approaches (trail and error, blind alleys etc), so you will need to make sure you nail it the first time.

As the others have said, start writing. Sketch out your introduction, get the literature review done while you do the analysis. Keep a detailed log of your methods and results so that you can easily transfer them into your thesis draft.

An extension would be worth looking into as well.

Journal Article Request (please help me!)
B

What about an interlibrary loan? Most university libraries have a service for research students, where an article not held by that library can be requested, and a scanned pdf sent to the student. Worth a try.

Should I quit my phd at the end of the third year
B

I recommend you have a meeting with your supervisor and discuss options. Before that, you should take stock of what you have in terms of data and output, and determine whether you could actually shape it into a PhD thesis. You may be surprised at what you have, especially given the time you have been working on it. If you can find enough to put into 3 data chapters, then you have a PhD.

Don't worry about publications at this stage, you can always publish after you have your PhD. Conference papers are are a 'nice to have', but not essential, especially if you aren't on top of your thesis.

It would be a waste of 3 years if you quit, and you would always have regrets.

Bullying supervisors - what really is the best strategy to deal with it?
B

Option 2 is the best approach.
In standing up to someone, you do need to come across as someone worthy of their respect, rather than as a victim. Huxley's anecdote was hilarious and right on the mark.

Due to personal reason have to quit my Ph.D.
B

Are you advanced enough in your PhD to be able to carry on as an external student? If you started last January, that means you have nearly 18 months of work behind you. What you need to weigh up is whether you want to start over again, or continue with where you are at with your current supervisor - just without the convenience of face to face contact.

5 months to go and a mountain to climb...
B

Keep in mind that his key message is about optimising the time you do have, whether its 1 hour a day or 20.

Chapter conclusions
B

I'm from the geographic sciences, and my disucssion and conclusion for each data chapter was rolled into one. My approach was to cover off what was in the chapter aims/objects, and discuss the outcomes in relation to previous literature i.e. how my work added to the state of knowledge about the subject. In my discussion I also provided a summary of sorts, but it was integrated into the broader discussion.

5 months to go and a mountain to climb...
B

I suggest you read the blog of James Hayton.

Word count query
B

There is a uniform word limit of 100,000 for a PhD thesis from my university. Of course there will plenty of variation within that limit depending on the discipline. My PhD in spatial science (remote sensing) is just over 60,000.