Overview of Eds

Recent Posts

Anyone else feel too stupid to be doing a PhD?
Avatar for Eds

If you're only a month in, then you're probably taking it too seriously as yet.


But don't take that to extremes!

MA in History challenges - too high or too low ?
Avatar for Eds

It's a piece of cake. Read loads. Read EVERYTHING. Write esssays with ten footnotes per page and a four-page bibliography. Just right everything you've got on that particular subject. They'll throw a merit at you. For a distinction, just structure it slightly.

Advice on first year literature report
Avatar for Eds

Are you in molecular physics?

Employment after PhD / EngD
Avatar for Eds

Where? and, who for? are the main questions.

plz help me fill the survey for my dissertation.
Avatar for Eds

Blimey! Gonna have to move to Singapore... the highest income level is SG$10,000... = < £5,000!

On edit: Surely the only respondants this survey requires are 'International students in Singapore.' You might find one or two of them here, but.

what is the best plagiarism detection tool?
Avatar for Eds

In other news, I note that Hiini hasn't actually said *why* s/he needs the plagarism detector? Always interested in numbnuts getting busted because they think (older!) people are daft :D

Threats from supervisor
Avatar for Eds

@YGTger- the 'community' would really need to understand the background before advising; and it sounds like that might come close to identify you in doing so? Certainly sounds bizarre though; professional supervisors tend not to purposefully sabotage their own candidates' chances.

@ToL- that's one of those elements of law that varies by jurisdiction. IIRC, in the UK it's not illegal to make such recordings, but it would be to publish them without consent. Elsewhere might be diferent (the USofA springs to mind).

Failed 1st year viva...I seriously need some advice
Avatar for Eds

Quote From lordsainsbury:
Thank you all for your kind words and support. I've since gone for some counseling help regarding my anxiety about this situation. I think I've heard what I needed to hear, but it definitely had to be gotten off of my chest. I will go for the PhD again. If things don't work out a second time, then at least I won't have any regrets. My supervisor never said no to a re-attempt and even said that she would support me no matter which path I choose. She just doesn't personally recommend it.


Good man! You'll stick around here and talk us through it I hope.

Quote From TreeofLife:
Yes it's the same everywhere unfortunately. People at my university have had 3 hour 1st year vivas where they are grilled on every little detail because the examiner knows their work inside out and then other people (like me) have a 1 hour viva where the examiners have no idea about the work and just nod at whatever is said. Neither strategy is particularly helpful.


Classic!

How glad are you that the PhD thesis is not graded?
Avatar for Eds

The reason being, that the thesis is only presented at the viva, but is not awarded until any corrections (if any) are done. So the point is is that all PhD's examined are of different grades, but all those that are awarded, are the same grade.

Applying for phd studentship with no msc?
Avatar for Eds

If it does say 'and /or masters' then it is the bachelor's that is moot, not the masters.

Turning thesis into book
Avatar for Eds

If you haven't read or glanced at Dunleavy's 'Authoring a PhD' then it's probably too late; but chapter nine would help you.

Failed 1st year viva...I seriously need some advice
Avatar for Eds

Go for it mate. Remember that- excepting Polio ;) - 'that which does not kill us makes us stronger.' The point about failure- or at least *a* point- is that we can learn from it, and not repeat the mistakes of the past. As long as all the technical stuff is still operative (funding etc), then I would take what your supervisor says with a pinch of salt; although she has your interests at heart, they are finely balanced against her's and those of her employer, for whom it is better not to recruit than to fail. From your point of though, look at it like this- you were ambushed, and still survived (if only just!). You have a second opportunity to prove yourself and demonstrate the paucity of their current perspective.
I suggest you take it.

Third class admission and funding chances
Avatar for Eds

Well yeah... what if they ask whether your current grading is reflective of your overall commitment? As ToL said above, unless you've got majorly-mitigating circumstances.

Starting a new journal and looking for contributors
Avatar for Eds

Will yours be peer-reviewed?

Starting a new journal and looking for contributors
Avatar for Eds

I take it the revisions are usually diametrically opposed to your original thesis?!