======= Date Modified 26 Sep 2009 23:01:57 =======
======= Date Modified 26 Sep 2009 23:01:06 =======
Hi BHC, I'm not jumping on a band wagon, just remembering what it was like to be 18 - 21, and the subject of plenty of unwanted lust from men old enough to be my father and grandfather - that was not a nice situation, I think it might be hard for men to understand just how vulnerable women can feel, especially young women away from home. I can remember feeling like prey when a tutor asked me to get up and turn around so he and his colleague could see me from all angles - they were the same age as my dad, which made the whole thing even more shocking (and I mean that in the deepest sense of the word)for me. I did it because I was 17, but I felt like crap afterwards, and dropped the course. As Bug and I have said, this satire fell flat, and looks to many people like the real deal, so it will make young women feel endangered (this is not just about offence). As you say, this sort of thing happens more than we like to think and I just think it's important that students should feel safe with their lecturers, wether there is a genuine threat or not this may seem like an academic situation, but the sense of threat women can feel about theses things, especially when there is a power inbalance, is tangable, and far from academic.
It was his personal decision to write the piece the way he did, he didn't have to accept the offer, plenty of others refused - I don't think he should be censored, just more mindful of how many of his students might feel. And yes, I think a degree of self censorship in writing for publication is always a must - one mans freedom is another's prison. I'd be saying the same thing about a woman VC who'd writen the piece about young men - I was quite alarmed by Germaine Greer's book.