Overview of marasp

Recent Posts

London direction--help?
M

London Euston, and then catch the underground to Tottenham - a 20 minute trip. If you are coming for the day and wish to travel around, buy a travelcard for underground, bus, etc. It's cheaper. Otherwise use an oyster card, or simply buy your tickets at the station to use on the train (underground).

The reports of my PhD thesis arrived 7 months late!
M

Yes, it took ages, I know. Your case is extreme. Can you not talk to someone about this?

PhD Decision Letter for the Fall, 2014
M

I had received a couple of similar letters when applying for PhDs in 2006. Had you contacted a potential supervisor to discuss the topic before applying? Basically, they say no. Don't lose hope. Apply to other universities, and reapply to the same university later on, after talking to a potential supervisor.

Hotdesking as a PhD student?
M

Hotdesking doesn't work for everyone. While I lived in the city where I did my PhD, there was a hotdesking policy in my department, for PhD students. This is particularly common in the humanities, I think.

I found it a bit frustrating, not having my own space to work. Changing desks all the time disorganised me. In the end, I had no option but work from home. I can concentrate better when I know I have my own space, as I mentally assign this space with work.

Win a Scholarship worth up to £1,000 with FindAMasters & FindAPhD
M

Can you please give us the link of the facebook group as well? For some reason, the links that you have provided do not work for me. Thank you.

PhD Resubmission, Feelings of Inadequacy Watching Peers
M

Literarytheorist, welcome to my world! Having had my viva in late 2011 and after having received R&R, I resubmitted in May this year (because of a severe health issue), but I could not stop feeling jealousy having seen most of my peers graduating and getting lectureships or even, getting amazing jobs in the field, before even submitting their PhDs. Yet, I trained myself to stop caring. I put my health and my abilities first.

It is possible to stop caring and comparing yourself to others. Delete your facebook account, do your best, and stay positive. What difference does it make to you, if X peer has a PhD and a career? Good for them, but so what? How does this affect you? It doesn't. You see my point? Everyone is different, and I do believe that good things come to those who wait.

You need to train yourself to promote every single positive aspect of your academic life (that's what my counsellor said to me). Do not see the glass as have empty but as half full. Evidently, in academia one has to be selfish to succeed (again, this advice comes from my counsellor). Embrace yourself for who you are, and learn to promote the best of you when with your peers. Academia is like advertising: you need to be convincing.

PhD Resubmitted: How Long Before Examiners' Report?
M

Quote From literarytheorist:
Looks like I could be waiting for a while then marasp. How are you (not) keeping your mind off it? Wish i could go abroad but I'll have to content myself with a few bubble baths and a manicure when there is some free time.


I don't really have the time to get stressed. I keep myself very busy, trying to publish as much as possible, and I work long hours. I also have a couple of conference papers to present in late September and I am getting ready for them. Soon, I will be in a third world country for two months, without internet connection. Which means that I should make the most of the internet and using the UK libraries while I can. To make a long story short, this travelling is about research - I combined law and human rights in my PhD, with case-studies from third world countries. Research that involves loads of travelling.

You should definitely treat yourself. A visit to your local SPA sounds like a great idea. Trying to keep yourself busy really helps. Make sure you stay healthy / get healthier (I know that many of us neglect our health while doing the PhD). I am still losing the PhD weight gain. 10 more kilos to go!

Mara Sp.

:( Revise and resubmit PhD thesis in 12 months!!! Success stories?
M

Quote From locke_211:
Thanks! I posted a message here right after I resubmitted saying how stressed I was and how I was convinced it would fail, so the email came completely out of the blue! It was an email from the internal examiner, cc'd to the external, my supervisor and to the PGR office, I guess in advance of the final official confirmation from the PGR office itself - so a nice 'we want you to know this as soon as possible', I guess!

It said:

"[The external examiner] and I have now read your revised thesis, conferred, and I am glad to say that we have agreed to recommend to the PGR board that it be awarded a PhD. I'm attaching our comments. We both think you did an excellent job in responding to our comments on the first draft, and that the thesis is now well structured and works very well. You write with great intelligence and subtlety, and it is a fine piece of work. Well done!

[Internal examiner]."

The reports both just recommend it be passed as it is, while lightly criticising a few aspects and highly praising others. No calls for further minor revisions at all - though I bank on one final typo sweep!

My disastrous viva was in December 2012, and since then I have gone through two long periods where I just wasn't going to bother resubmitting. They wanted the order of the chapters completely changing, an entirely new argument about the material going from start to finish, and three of the six chapters, once moved, completely rewritten to accommodate their new position and the new argument, and then an entirely new conclusion. But I did exactly that and they think I did it well! Waking up today was bizarre - it's like I don't remember not having this hanging over me!

I want to stress that anyone given 12 months should have a very clear list of what exact changes they want. Even if they are huge changes, the examiners should leave you in no doubt of what changes need to happen in order for them to pass it.



Congrats!!!!!!!! Excellent news!!!!! I am still waiting for my verdict but I hope I report here, with a positive result.

Mara Sp.

revise and resubmit
M

Good luck to those who are still waiting, and congrats Sunflower! It looks like you are getting there, very very soon!

PhD Resubmitted: How Long Before Examiners' Report?
M

I have to wait for five months. I will know the results in the end of October. This is because the external is abroad on research... and as a matter of fact, I will be abroad on research too soon, for a couple of months. Therefore, I am not complaining. But they said to me that usually s takes 2.5 - 3 months.

Volunteering at Univ. of the People
M

Thanks, I have sent them my CV. I suppose I have nothing to lose.

Happily childfree?
M

I loved reading the article. It's a bit different to what I usually read and I fully understand and respect your agonising feelings to settle down and have a family. I would like to add here the opposite point-of-view, as I think that it should be presented as well. I am sure the internet has plenty of articles, if you search for the term 'childfree'.

Some people have no intention or desire to procreate. They have no maternal or paternal instinct. They may even feel uncomfortable being around kids. They don't wish to have children, for various reasons.

Childfree is a kind of stigma. In a child-centric society, the childfree (and particularly childfree women) are called names, from selfish and immature, to (even) child-haters. They are 'brainwashed' everyday, in order to be converted to 'the norm': 'it's different when they are yours!', and 'who will look after you when you are old?'. I know of a childfree lady who had tubal ligation - her own mother does not talk to her any more because of what she did!

Society always attacks and interrogates people: 'why did you not have kids?
Yet, nobody asks a person for their reasons *why* they had them.

Childfree people experience emotional pain, because nobody understands and respects their right and reasons to remain childfree. They are 'ostracised' as different.

Ultimately, as I said earlier, whether to have children or not is a personal decision. There is huge polarisation between parents and non-parents, but this should not be the case. It's like comparing apples and oranges. Both views should, and must be accepted equally.

Happily childfree?
M

Not sure if this piece of advice is right, but a lady who is a VIP academic once told me that the best way for a woman to combine motherhood and a successful academic career is to
a) either have children early in life (e.g. before starting or completing a PhD) or b) have children later in life (late 30s, early 40s).

The first scenario allows women to raise their children before starting their academic career; then it is easier to focus on academia while children are at school.

The second scenario is also a possibility, as it is easier to get back to academia after a short academic break, than starting from zero.

Happily childfree?
M

I noticed that the childfree groups on FB are full of academics. It must be an academia-related epidemic.

Happily childfree?
M

Thank you for sharing these experiences with me.

There is a book called 'mama phd'. I read it a couple of years ago, and it is a very good read. I hope you all find what you are after.