Overview of missspacey

Recent Posts

Quality of today's PhDs: article in Times Higher
M

I have been told that a candidate rarely enters the viva examination room without the examiners already having their decision made as to whether candidate is going to pass or fail. If a pass is on the cards, a candidate will have to really mess up, possibly raising doubts as to whether the work is their own etc, to end up failing.

Thus, there is no point getting nervous in the viva as our fates are usually already decided ! :-(

Surname project
M

This link is now working:

http://www.publicprofiler.org/worldnames1/

Obama
M

Quote From juno:

It seems to me that Americans (and not just African Americans) worry about/hang on to their ethnic origins more than many other people. I have met Americans who tell me that they are also Irish, but in reality they just had a great-great-great-grandparent who was Irish! Similarly Obama is always described as "African American", but wasn't he born and bred in the US to a white mother and a black father? Isn't he just "American"?



This is exactly what I think about American culture too.

I was watching a clip from CNN where 3 white reporters were flummoxed about whether it was correct to call Obama the first 'black president' or the first 'African American president'. Viewers had phoned in after taking offence to Obama being referred to as 'black'.

Quality of today's PhDs: article in Times Higher
M

Quote From swantje:

Quote From missspacey:

Swantje, I'm talking about academic jobs, not PhD positions.
I did say for 'most countries', maybe I should have 'some', but I certainly didn't say 'all'.
I know of lots of people who have had no problems getting academic jobs in other countries - especially European countries.
But try further a field, for instance the US or Canada.


(if i read your post correctly you were talking about phd applicants)

i really doubt that. if you check out departmental websites they are full of foreigners, even in canada and the us. some aren't, and there's usually a good reason for that (crappy uni).
i have however noticed that, generally, english academics tend to not like going to live abroad. and if they do, then they tend to come back to the uk after a while. i'm at an international institute right now and english people (and americans) are always in the minority compared to all the other nationalities. i find that surprising.


British and US academics have less incentive to go abroad because the opportunities and pay in their own countries are very good.

But, for instance, if I wanted to go for a job in Canada, a Canadian applicant would be favoured before myself. This is stated on the job adverts. In my field at least, when I see foreigners in faculty positions in the US or Canada it's normally a non-tenured or non-tenure track position. Of course, foreigners will get jobs, particularly in subjects such as international studies, but it's much harder for a foreign applicant to compete in North American, than it is for an American or Canadian to secure a position here.

Obama
M

Given McCain's choice of VP - I think Obama has the election in the bag!

Surname project
M

Very interesting! Unfortunately, it's still inundated with traffic.

Quality of today's PhDs: article in Times Higher
M

Swantje, I'm talking about academic jobs, not PhD positions.

I did say for 'most countries', maybe I should have 'some', but I certainly didn't say 'all'.

I know of lots of people who have had no problems getting academic jobs in other countries - especially European countries.

But try further a field, for instance the US or Canada.

Quality of today's PhDs: article in Times Higher
M

Quote From thecoastman:

Wow, I bet the postgrads in his Department are happy. Could you imagine if he was your supervisor? I hope he doesn't supervise...


LOL, I didn't think of that!

Actually it looks like he's just being a snob - he was educated at Oxford and it seems it is only Oxford that has the 'significant and substantial contribution' standard for their DPhil requirements.

Prospects of getting a graduate/commercial job after a PhD - glum
M

======= Date Modified 11 06 2008 09:06:18 =======
I'm seriously thinking of leaving academia after my PhD. However, I am concerned that I have absolutely no chance of entering the commerical job market, particularly in the ultra competitive industries of law/financial services.

Has age and/or lack of commercial experience been a problem for anyone?

Quality of today's PhDs: article in Times Higher
M

======= Date Modified 30 Aug 2008 18:59:39 =======

This article pissed me off. I don't believe British PhD are 'distilled' or of a lower standard compared with the US or Europe - in fact I think British PhDs are generally better. The standard for a British PhD is 'a distinct contribution' and 'originality'. That seems fair to me. I don't see why it should be a 'significant and substantial contribution' as one's research may not turn out that way.

However, I do think the British PhD experience is blighted by poor research skills and training.

It annoys me when academics get on their soapbox about academic standards but fail to mention the practicalities - such as who funds a student to spend 6 years studying for a PhD?

The prof. also mentions that it's harder for British PhD holders to get jobs, but I think this is more to do with the open-door policy that UK universities operate. Now I don't have a problem with that in theory - it means the best person gets the job regardless of nationality/citizenship. However, this policy is not reciprocal. Most other countries will favour citizenship or permanent residents, which places British PhD applicants (or other foreign applicants) bottom of the list.

Private Messaging is Here! See... we told you it would be!
M

Very nice!(up)

Obama
M

======= Date Modified 29 Aug 2008 16:53:13 =======
Grrrrr my post didn't go through - but then the PM function appeared...whoo!

Getting back to Obama...

Was he at the Pantheon? :p That stage setting was a little gauche.

He says he'll eliminate US dependence on middle-eastern oil in 10 years....yeah right (unless he plans to invade Canada). He talks the talk, but his actual policies seem lacking. However, if I were an American I would definitely support Barack because of his long-term anti-war and pro-gay marriage stance.

I wish Al Gore would shut up - he managed to plug 'inconvenient truth' into his speech again.

This election is surely a one-horse race for Barack? My only worry is that America is a still far too racist for a black president.

Does it sound like my prospective supervisor is attracted to me?
M

Ooo it's like Mills and Boon novel.

Seriously, don't bother! You'll get stung or your supervisor will get fired. Some universities have blanket bans on staff- student relationships (no matter if you're a UG or PG).

Time Required!
M

Isn't an EdD a 'professional PhD' i.e., it involves some training/structured study (possibly not). Thus, a PhD would give you greater flexibility to work at home etc.

Four Letter Word--Change one letter
M

Toll