Overview of pm133

Recent Posts

What University is your better option?
P

Quote From DavidMike:
Quote From pm133:
Your question makes no sense.


What else do you need to write answer for this question? They are considered based distance and the standards.


There is no such thing as a "better university". rewt above describes the bare minimum you need to consider before anyone can help you.

Moving all deadlines to a future date...
P

Quote From Tudor_Queen:
Hi experienced PhDers...
I've got myself in a bit of a mess mentally... I am so sick of my work - I just can't face it. In 3 and a half weeks I go away for 6 weeks on a study visit (funded). It is a great privilege and I'm looking forward to it. I want to spend the next 3 and a half weeks preparing for it, instead of writing up my thesis, which I am getting NO WHERE on. It will mean having to move a whole series of deadlines to when I get back in mid June. I am in my final year but I believe I am entitled to a write up year (self funded). Is it up to me if I choose to move my deadlines like this? I know my supervisor won't be pleased but I really feel I have no option. I just feel SO demotivated about my thesis right now, and just hope that my trip will breathe new life into me (if I am prepared for it - that is having read up properly on what I'll be doing etc in advance of going).
Any advice? Is it ludicrous to tell my supervisor that I want to do this (i.e., move deadlines till after trip and just forget about my thesis for a while)?
Thanks
Tudor


I am probably not the best person to answer this because I had no deadlines and would not have tolerated any being placed on me. Personally, I think you have earned the right to decide your own timings on things and your supervisor should accept that.

PhD application dilemma
P

It might also be worth remembering that thousands of lecturers have just spent the last month on strike so their minds are probably on other things right now.

Does every study have to go in the thesis?
P

Quote From Tudor_Queen:
I've been feeling so demotivated, even though I have so much to do in such a short space of time (in fact, I think that's contributing to it). I'm having to write up the most boring study that didn't find anything and was just utter rubbish anyway. The other two studies I've done are probably enough data for the thesis. Do I HAVE to include this? I so cannot be bothered to write it up. There is NOTHING interesting about it and it is driving me insane.


No you dont have to include everything.
I left out one piece of published work because it didnt fit the story I was telling.
I also left out something else which didnt give an interesting answer.
It might help you to mention in the viva that your thesis doesnt include everything.

What University is your better option?
P

Your question makes no sense.

First year student, lost in topics, originality
P

Trying to come up with something original is part of the process and with it comes the constant fear that what you have done is wrong or irrelevant. Not sure you can avoid that risk I'm afraid.

Interview Tips
P

Incognito created this post 4 years ago.

Kicked off PhD
P

Quote From terriblestudent:
My own fault. Failed my first year report viva and am leaving my PhD. I had problems with getting equipment - and then there was a flood in the lab which meant that my actual report represented 2 weeks work rather than 1 years. But I got slated for everything - including my basic knowledge. I just couldn't engage my head and now I'm gone.

Question is - does anyone know how long you continue to be paid for? I still have rent to pay and could really do with another months stipend. If I appeal do you think I will still get paid?

I'm now looking for work - but it won't start tomorrow.


No idea about the appeal but you need to register for unemployment today as a priority before you do anything else. Do NOT tell your landlord you are out of work.

First year student, lost in topics, originality
P

You are to be congratulated for your original stance over your first supervisor and pursuing your favoured topic.
That took real guts and you should be proud of yourself for that.
It's really bad luck that someone else beat you to it.

The most important question is whether you have got over the disappointment or whether it is still messing up your thoughts?

My advice is to follow the topic which most interests you. Ask your supervisor for their opinion on originality and present the case for both sides.

Managing corrections -- working with sup. whilst working fulltime
P

Quote From Jamie_Wizard:
cheers for that pm133 :-)


In two years time when all this is over you will look back and wonder what all the fuss was about.
You just need to be patient at the moment.
It doesn't seem to be affecting your career anyway judging by your previous post.

Feeling lost due to the strike
P

Quote From bongmaster5000:


This is how industrial action works. If you don't like it, presumably you don't agree with strikes in principle. Sounds like the typical small-minded British attitude to trade unionism - grousing and bitterness when other workers take the initiative to stand up for themselves and protect hard-won rights and benefits that they themselves don't have/have lost. Because I don't have a decent defined-benefits pension, nobody should. Reverse solidarity. It stinks, frankly.



You appear to have asked me a question and then answered it yourself without bothering to give me the opportunity to speak for myself.
There is a word for that but I forget what it is.
In a normal conversation I would be allowed to respond in my own words, provoking further debate but in this case you have rushed to a conclusion about me based on absolutely no evidence at all. It's a very modern phenomenon.
Honestly, I blame Facebook and Twitter for this sort of thing.

Feeling lost due to the strike
P

Quote From bongmaster5000:
Quote From pm133:

I have no idea why you fully support your lecturers. They have deliberately targetted students with both the timing and duration of the strikes and for many students this will result in life changing drops in final grades.
Unfortunately I have no idea what to recommend here. There is an entire year of students being screwed over here. My own daughter is one of them although she is able to teach herself from books so will be OK.


'Deliberately targeted students' = withdrawn their labour in an effort to disrupt university processes so as to stand up for their employment rights - a course of action which is very close to winning significant concessions, by the way, which has basically discredited the narrative that this was unavoidable, pension fund hugely in deficit, no way around it, etc. We have won the right to an independent valuation. We have pushed back against unreasonable changes to our terms and conditions.

I have attended UCU branch meetings throughout the strike and I can assure you that the overwhelming sentiment is that everybody wants it over and done with as soon as possible with minimal harm to students' education. It is unfortunate that students are caught in the dispute but the nature of our jobs demands it if we want to employ collective bargaining.

This is how industrial action works. If you don't like it, presumably you don't agree with strikes in principle. Sounds like the typical small-minded British attitude to trade unionism - grousing and bitterness when other workers take the initiative to stand up for themselves and protect hard-won rights and benefits that they themselves don't have/have lost. Because I don't have a decent defined-benefits pension, nobody should. Reverse solidarity. It stinks, frankly.

I agree strongly with everything that PD has said.

OP, you should be fine - sorry that you have been affected, and I agree that it's not nice to miss contact hours - but PG is about independent study - sounds like you're doing it. Well done.


If minimising student disruption was the aim then why strike at the worst possible time of the year for them?
No I'm sorry but this was done deliberately. You can dress it up howeve you like but striking lecturers will cause untold damage to the futures of thousands of students. It really is unforgiveable.
Any striking should have either been done over the summer or should have been of limited duration. An entire month at this time of year is unacceptable.

Feeling lost due to the strike
P

Quote From pd1598:
For the record I'm a lecturer but I wasn't at a striking University. PM you are always going on about needing to stand up for yourself, well that is exactly what the lecturers have done. I guess you just don't like it when it affects you or your daughter? I suppose you think a strike would still be effective in the middle of summer? Lecturers don't ask to become rich (most won't) but have asked for the terms and conditions they signed up to to be protected.

.


So like I said, lecturers deliberately targetted their strikes at this time of year because it would have maximum impact, knowing full well students would suffer. That is where they lost the moral high ground.

As I explained earlier, my daughter will be fine because only one module is affected and she has taught herself after successfully asking the strikers to put the notes online, but countless thousands will not be.

Striking at this time was not the only option.

Funded Phd at low-rank uni or a masters at a top uni
P

Quote From Montanita:
I disagree. ive recently seen job applications which specifically ask for a degree from a RGroup universities. I think this is going to become more prominent with there currently being a movement in the UK away from the idea that everyone should go to university even if its to a low ranking university to do a pointless degree. Also speaking to lecturers I have heard many saying privately they look at PhDs from a well ranked university better than one from one lower down.


The number of job adverts specifying an RG university will be vanishingly small.
Same goes for the view of your lecturers. The reality is that most PhD positions attract a relatively small number of applications. Supervisors on the whole don't have the luxury of simply turning people down because of where they did their undergrad degree.

What you are witnessing here is a pocket of stupidity and snobbery in industry and academia which deeply hurts both. Some of the biggest companies in the world have even stopped asking for degrees altogether for some jobs because they know that only asking for Oxbridge grads seriously harms their business.

You mention above that with more people getting degrees that employers are likely to ask for more RGT graduates as a result. In fact this is not what employers do in practice. What they seek is experience - both life and work. You need a great degree from a recognised university and experience which makes you stand out if you ever harbour hopes of getting into the biggest companies.

I don't know who is advising undergraduates about choosing RG unis because of improved job prospects but they are doing young people a serious disservice when they do so.
Go to a recognised university, get a 1st class in your subject and secure some work experience directly related to the job you want even offering your services for free if needed. That all matters much more than coming from an RG uni.

Obtuse Supervisors
P

I think we are going to need a lot more detail if any of us are going to be able to help.
You sound close to the end of your tether though.