Overview of pm133

Recent Posts

Feeling lost due to the strike
P

Quote From snab9812:
Hi all!

How are you guys doing? I am a newbie here and would really like to have some sort of communication with strangers (soon friends) about my current studies.
I am in the final term of my masters and I am feeling anxious and lost especially due to the recent strike. Don't get me wrong, I totally support my lecturers on this matter. However, I need to be frank that losing A LOT of contact hours is not what I has signed up for. As taught master is only a year and I am an international student, I believed that I had much more to gain from the lost contact hours. I tried to work independently, did group discussion and tried to read as much articles that I could, yet, I did not feel the same satisfaction as attending classes.

And now, I am having break for the Easter and I need to carry on one research, two assignments and one dissertation. I am feeling overwhelmed of all this! I am uncertain of my capabilities right now and I am terrified if I could not produce great results.


Fuh! that feels good. I am sorry for this prattle. I just need to spill it out. Thanks for reading!

Feel free to drop at my new blog : https://sitiborhanudin.wixsite.com/academic


I have no idea why you fully support your lecturers. They have deliberately targetted students with both the timing and duration of the strikes and for many students this will result in life changing drops in final grades.
Unfortunately I have no idea what to recommend here. There is an entire year of students being screwed over here. My own daughter is one of them although she is able to teach herself from books so will be OK.

Can You Study PhD and Masters Degree At The Same Time?
P

It can be a good stepping stone if their undergrad degree is weak.
Also, DTCs appear designed to ensure the gap between undergrad and PhD is a bit smaller.
If I were to redo my PhD I would look for a DTC route now even with a 1st class.

Doing an advertised PhD topic at a different university
P

Quote From ThomF:
I've come across a PhD topic I am very interested in pursuing, however it's advertised at a university that does not appeal. Due to personal circumstance I am unable to relocate at this time and further to this, the university in question is not especially reputable. I wanted to understand if I am able to apply to undertake this topic elsewhere.

The topic is currently advertised as being a competition funded, in that it is in competition with other proposed PhD topics, with only some receiving the limited available funding. I assume some form of copyright exists, although I wondered if this topic fails to secure funding at this particular university if this would open up my options.

Thank you


An inability to relocate is fair enough but I have no idea what you mean when you say the university is not reputable.
I would echo the others. What you are suggesting is completely unethical. It seems odd to be talking about the reputation of this university when you are suggesting stealing research ideas from them.

Managing corrections -- working with sup. whilst working fulltime
P

Quote From Jamie_Wizard:
.
.


You do realise you could simply have ignored my advice instead of responding with this self indulgent petulance right?
Of course everyone is desperate to finish when they have corrections but right now it is you who is asking for advice.
A little less defensiveness would help you. Most of us get through this without unduly pressuring our supervisors and snapping at those who express advice we dont like or want to hear. There is a clash between your view of how important your situation is and your supervisors view of it. At the end of a PhD you become yesterday's news as far as your supervisors are concerned. You have flown the nest. This happens to virtually everyone. Your supervisors have other priorities now and you would be well advised to be more respectful of that. It's not their fault that you are in this position. What you are posting here sounds a bit self absorbed.

Brand New PhD Student & Feeling Hopeless
P

Quote From lovelylisa83:
Hi everyone,

I am new here and am six weeks into beginning my PhD studies here at a uni in Brisbane. I am feeling overwhelmed and hopeless. I am meeting with my supervisors every fortnight up until confirmation and when I had my last meeting with them, I got told that I need to contribute ideas to our discussions and I need to be recommending books/journal articles to them to read already....I thought this is something that you should be able to do towards the end of your PhD when you are the 'expert' in your field? I am honestly worried about my next meeting with them, which is this week. I sat in my car and just cried after the last meeting. I just feel so dumb and feel like I shouldn't be here. I am so exhausted, nothing I am doing at the moment seems to be right and imposter syndrome is hitting me big time. I also suffer from depression and anxiety and these are both flaring up big time at the moment.

I am so sorry about the ranting, but I just feel really alone at the moment and need to know whether what I am experiencing is 'normal' and any advice/suggestions from other PhD students who are further along.

Lisa


I really wouldn't worry about this. Your supervisors are doing what they should do by explaining what is expected of you. Just take their advice on board and adjust what you do for the next meeting.

You are perhaps realising the scale of the step up from undergraduate level. It is massive and nothing can prepare you for it. Not one of us found that journey easy. It is absolutely normal to feel stupid and out of your depth. Your supervisors will also be feeling that way with their own research. I guarantee it. If anyone is telling you different then they cannot be engaged in proper worthwhile research because by definition nobody engaged in leading edge research knows exactly what they are doing.

40+ and looking for Phd. Would appreciate your advise.
P

Quote From anonymous1977
I agree that it is ok if you don't want to help.


Oh what a relief. I wouldn't have slept a wink tonight if you hadn't blessed me with your agreement :

-D

Managing corrections -- working with sup. whilst working fulltime
P

I'm not sure I understand. Is there a reason why you are emailing your supervisors about a strategy for success?
Are you giving them your corrections in a piecemeal fashion?
You were given a list of needed corrections so is there a reason why you didn't complete them all before handing it back to your supervisors?
This is your PhD not theirs and it sounds to me that you might be struggling to accept total ownership of the process. I am guessing that is because you are absolutely desperate to get this all finished. Unfortunately it doesn't work like that and you need to be careful that you are not pissing your supervisor off by trying to force the issue.

40+ and looking for Phd. Would appreciate your advise.
P

You have misunderstood my point and I detect a hint of frost in your answer above so I will wish you well and bail from the discussion :-D
I would however respectfully suggest that you don't bite the ankles of people who are trying to help you if you want further responses.

40+ and looking for Phd. Would appreciate your advise.
P

I have re-read my response to you several times and I honestly can't see what I have said to make you come to that conclusion.

Unable to complete Ph.D.! Please advise to quit easily!
P

Another option could be to go for PhD award by paper publications but to be honest if your friend has only completed 20% of the research work in 3.2 years then it sounds like they will be leaving with nothing. I cant see how enoug work has been done to even justify a Masters degree here because 20% is less than 8 months and I assume that this will be both a highly fragmented and innefficient 8 months,

Career Break Collapse
P

Quote From MattG242:
So...I took a wild, mid-life career break to pursue what I thought would might a life-changing switch to pure maths. Finished an OU degree, got myself on a Masters and now...I'm falling over. Can't get my head round stuff, spending hours on the simplest problems, suffering from a constant sense of panic and fear. It's to a certain extent my own fault - I went in gung ho on a difficult topic and got stubborn with it, and I don't think I've approached it in the most effective way, but here we are.

I'm trying to figure out whether I struggle through, and potentially fail (this is a real option - everyone's saying 'stick with it' but I'm honestly nowhere and about 80% sure it's going to be a disaster), or gently back down and return to 'real life'. I've a decent CV in my original career and even a bit of freelance experience, it's not like I'm doomed I think. Just wondering what's going to look worse, ultimately...


I took a similar path as well, selling my business and taking a year off to just read technical books. I then went back to uni at 39 for a full masters degree followed by a PhD. In my case, I wanted to figure out what my capability was. I didnt break until the end of my Phd but the story is the same. Maybe you are now seeing where the end of your potential is with regards to pure maths. You can be disappointed obviously but you will also be able to say you found out where your limit was. Most people are too scared to even try finding out. In my case it was the pressure of being in an environment of having to report my progress to someone which broke me. Using that knowledge I now run my own business and I am much happier. Maybe there is value in you taking a step back and thinking about whether your problem is similar.

Funded Phd at low-rank uni or a masters at a top uni
P

Quote From bongmaster5000:


Dont mess around worrying about the so-called ranking of universities. Companies worth working for dont care where you studied.
What matters is what you achieve during your phd, your relationship with your supervisor and that your university has the resources you need to succeed - computational in your case I think. Leave all the worrying about university rankings to schoolchildren and parents who dont know any better and are dazzled by such nonsense as league tables.


Couldn't agree more. Take the PhD. Rankings at PhD level are even more meaningless than usual. Plus, to coin a phrase, a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.


It really is incredible how many people buy into this league table rubbish. I keep hearing from people who talk about being at a Russell Group uni as though their presence there has somehow impregnated them with special magical powers. I never know whether to laugh or cry at this.

I think the way to break this problem might be to do something as drastic as ensuring there is a common curriculum and a common set of exams across all universities in the UK. When you are charging students just under £10k a year, there needs to be some meaningful way for them to know what they are buying. Right now the current system encourages and rewards corruption and bullshitting.

Can You Study PhD and Masters Degree At The Same Time?
P

Quote From DavidMike:
It may be impossible but do you know any options?


The only sensible way to do that would be to go through a 1+3 PhD where the first year is a taught masters year with mini projects followed by the 3 year PhD. In the UK they are called DTCs.

40+ and looking for Phd. Would appreciate your advise.
P

There is absolutely no logical reason whatsoever for your age being an issue but that will depend on the country you want to work in. The USA seems to be pretty backwards and obsessed with youth over experience but in the UK for example, things are much more enlightened in that regard. Either way, there is nothing you can do about it now. You have already spent enough years doing what others expect of you. It's time to get on with what you want.
When you get your PhD you will be perfectly placed to enter academia, secondary or primary education or even home tutoring via your own company. I did my PhD in my forties and now run my own company. Lots of people do this. Doing a PhD with the sole aim of getting an academic job is a very poor reason in my opinion. The chances of securing a permanent job are so small that you really need a good solid backup plan. In my opinion you should do a PhD only because you enjoy something so much that you want to spend a few years dedicating yourself to it.
Dont put all your eggs in one basket. Every academic job attracts hundreds of applicants and academia is full of postdocs in their mid-thirties and in several cases early 40s still trying to secure their first permanent post when most of us are on our second or third careers. It really is a horror show. I personally know three people who were around 40 before they got their first permanent post. One guy had spent 17 years on temporary academic contracts!!!!

Funded Phd at low-rank uni or a masters at a top uni
P

Quote From chris89culley:
My final year project supervisor (I'm a final year undergrad) is offering me a fully funded Phd (with 15k pa stipend) to research machine learning in the genomic space which is super cool and interesting. He studied his Phd at Cambridge and is very strong in his field but the only downside it that I am at an ex-poly very low-rank university.

I have also been accepted at Manchester to do an Msc in AI which I think should lead to a funded phd thereafter and Manchester is one of the best uni's in the country for research in this area.

So , the question is, what the hell do I do?

I don't want to stay in academia after finishing a Phd so I need to know if a) employers will care if I have a Phd from x low rank uni rather than y high rank uni? b) if at a Phd level (people have said) its most important that you get on with the supervisor, like the topic etc and that uni prestige is meaningless at that level ?


Dont mess around worrying about the so-called ranking of universities. Companies worth working for dont care where you studied.
What matters is what you achieve during your phd, your relationship with your supervisor and that your university has the resources you need to succeed - computational in your case I think. Leave all the worrying about university rankings to schoolchildren and parents who dont know any better and are dazzled by such nonsense as league tables.