Overview of pm133

Recent Posts

PhD stipend and student loan repayments
P

Quote From henrytudorvii:
Hi All,

I will be starting a PhD soon, and had a question regarding student loan repayments since my situation is a bit odd.

Wanted to ask if anyone knows whether PhD stipends count as income towards student loan repayments. Without going into too much detail, I have supplementary income that is below the income tax threshold, including some from an ISA, and am certain that I will cross the repayment threshold.

Would PhD stipends count as income to the SLC?

Thanks,


Your stipend is tax free and doesnt count towards anything like that.
You dont need to declare it to HMRC and so it wont affect your repayments liability.
If I am wrong about this could someone please tell me ASAP because I will owe HMRC a fortune :)

Will I be too old to apply for Ph.D. at the age of 30
P

Graduated at 48 and I am mentally sharper and more focussed than I ever was as a 20 something.
Age is absolutely meaningless.
Attitude is everything.

Revise and resubmit-passed viva exam second time round!
P

One way to cope with trying to ignore what others are doing in comparison is to remember that a career is a marathon and not a sprint. The person who has blown away everyone at the age of 25 with a ton of papers, awards, prizes and applause still has to sustain a 40+ year career, still has to figure out the meaning of their own life, still has to negotiate their midlife crises (more than one), still has to go through decisions about life partners, marriage, children, buying a house, pensions, friendships, loneliness, illness, death and a vast host of other things.
In essence we are all the same and no amount of career success will change the fact that when we are dead, within a few years we will be forgotten along with all our opinions and achievements. Even our own great grandchildren probably wont know we existed.
We are riding around on a tiny rock (Earth) which is spinning around a vast ocean of empty space. Nothing matters really so dont sweat the small stuff.

None of that was meant to sound depressing at all. It is quite a liberating thought when you consider it.

IP Theft
P

This sort of thing seems to happen all the time.
It is one of the reasons why I resist talking to anyone about ongoing work or potential future work in any sort of forum until I have either published it or at least am almost ready to submit.
People just cannot be trusted in such a competitive arena as academia.

PhD fellow vs PhD candidate
P

OK to me candidate sounds a bit passive in that sense.
Student sounds more pro active.

Applying for RA positions instead of role requiring PhD...
P

Time for bed I think lol.

Applying for RA positions instead of role requiring PhD...
P

Quote From Tudor_Queen:
Quote From pm133:
[quote]
I know I risk annoying you here but I have to say again that I still feel you give the impression that you care too much about how you think others will perceive your decisions. You posted on a similar theme elswhere when talking about how you prefer the prestige of certain job titles for PhD students. The symptom of this is overthinking simple things and assigning undue importance to things which are unimportant.

I might be wrong here but that is what I feel is happening in your case. Of course its almost impossible to be certain when chatting over the internet.


I'm not annoyed : ) I assure you though that I don't care/mind about how others perceive my decisions (if you knew me then you wouldn't even entertain the thought!). However, I do care about the implications of my decisions. Those are two different things as I tried to explain earlier.

In this case, I agree that I am being a little too weary / paranoid and overthinking a simple decision. But that's because of my PhD and some of the decisions I made there - not realising that it would have an impact later.


Yeah, like I said, it is very difficult to read people online.

OK lets deal with the second paragraph of your post above.
I am not surprised you are like this after your experiences with your previous supervisor.
Obviously you want to make sure you dont make the wrong decisions but also you dont want to be crippled by paranoia either.
The obvious suggestion then would be to find out whether this is likely to be a problem or not by extending your enquiries beyond the circle of people you have already spoken to. You have uncertainty and in the void of uncertainty, fear and doubt pile in, drink all the beer and play their music too loud.
I have been drinking too much red bull and watching too much House........

Seeking recommendations on solicitors who specialise in academic appeals
P

Quote From ManOnMeaning:
Hello!

Does anyone know (preferably from experience) any solicitors who specialise in academic appeals?

I passed my viva and was given major corrections which I completed but I was stunned to be told that I'm only being awarded an MPhil + minor amendments.

Thanks!


It is not unheard of for major corrections to turn into an outright fail.
Did you get an explanation of why?

Applying for RA positions instead of role requiring PhD...
P

Quote From Tudor_Queen:
I suppose one way it could be seen as a negative might be that I already have lots of RA experience and time is passing, so I should be trying to get on to a postdoc rather than taking on a fixed term contract as an RA... that could be a valid concern I suppose.


If you were turning down postdoc positions for RA roles I would agree.
What do you do if you turn down RA positions whilst chasing a prestigious postdoc but dont land the postdoc?
What if the RA positions have also dried up whilst you were looking elsewhere?
I think the key is to stay in the game by whatever means are at your disposal. Dont reject the hammer because everyone wants to see a shiny screwdriver. Sometimes the best tool for beating the crap out of something is the ugly beast of a thing you want to pretend is not on your shelf.

That sounded way better in my head :-D

Applying for RA positions instead of role requiring PhD...
P

Quote From Tudor_Queen:
I suppose one way it could be seen as a negative might be that I already have lots of RA experience and time is passing, so I should be trying to get on to a postdoc rather than taking on a fixed term contract as an RA... that could be a valid concern I suppose.


Well the easy answer to that is that you take the RA because good intentions dont pay the bills. During the RA work you actively look for postdocs. The point is that even during a postdoc you will be on the lookout either for the next postdoc or some independent funding via fellowships or whatever. You are never static. Always looking for the next step.

I have a gut feeling that you might be missing the bigger picture here due to what you describe as paranoia in the above post. The bigger picture is that when moving forwards, real life forces you to sometimes take a meandering path with sideways movements. As long as you can explain the rationale behind your actions and decisions there should be no problem explaining that to a reasonable person and you wouldnt want to work for an unreasonable person again anyway.

I know I risk annoying you here but I have to say again that I still feel you give the impression that you care too much about how you think others will perceive your decisions. You posted on a similar theme elswhere when talking about how you prefer the prestige of certain job titles for PhD students. The symptom of this is overthinking simple things and assigning undue importance to things which are unimportant.

I might be wrong here but that is what I feel is happening in your case. Of course its almost impossible to be certain when chatting over the internet.

PhD fellow vs PhD candidate
P

Given that the PhD is not really like being a student at all, there isn't a good term.
I used PhD Student but it didnt feel like a good description.
Using PhD Fellow is absolutely ridiculous. Anyone doing that around me would have had the piss taken out of them mercilessly until they stopped it. PhD candidate doesnt make sense at all to me. Candidate for what?

Politic - Pay scholarship back? Should I?
P

I understand what you are saying but creditors can chase you for years for debt. It's all very well saying you have no assets now but unless you always plan to rent or own nothing you can expect sleepless nights unless you get closure,

Personally I am from neither camp that you describe in your second sentence.
If I owe money I make sure I pay it on a point of principle, not just to get a creditor off my back.
Having said that, negotiating with the creditor can usually result in an agreed reduced debt (takes me back a couple of decades to when I met my wife and had to help her get out of debt).
Getting closure on stuff like this is very important for most people.
I can't imagine just walking away and hoping everything will be OK. I would be sick with worry.

Politic - Pay scholarship back? Should I?
P

Quote From TreeofLife:
I really doubt they will pursue this, secondly, even if they do, there's not much they can do, particularly if: you don't still work there or they don't know who you do work for; you don't own a house or if you do it's a different one to the address they have; you don't own a car or any expensive assets.

Basically, in order to recover this "debt", they would have to take you to court (threatening letters from collection agencies don't count) and they would only do so if they think you have assets of some type for them to recover. The reality is they probably won't bother.

Source: I used to work in debt recovery.


The sentence you used above "they PROBABLY won't bother" is the reason why the OP should play this by the book unless they particularly enjoy sleepless nights, crushing uncertainty and even the slightest chance of serious debt. The OP may not have assets to sell but that won't stop a County Court Judgment being served on them. That will cause them credit rating problems for years at the very least.

Also, as you know if you worked in debt recovery, it is a trivial thing to track someone down. There is an entire industry dedicated towards it.

Ignoring any debt is a potentially disastrous thing to do.

Applying for RA positions instead of role requiring PhD...
P

Yeah, I must admit I can't see how it can hinder you. Experience is experience.
Is there a particular reason you think it might be a hindrance?
Has someone in a position of authority or knowledge told you it might be or is this a gut feeling you have?
What is driving your concern?

Politic - Pay scholarship back? Should I?
P

Do not simply ignore this. Just because you don't work there doesn't mean you can't get yourself in a world of trouble.

A studentship is not a contract of service so normal rules about being paid to work may not apply.

You need to do this by the "book" and the book in this case is your contract. That will tell you what you do and do not have to do. Once you have done that, as advised by bewildered and TQ, your student union might be able to help.