Overview of screamingaddabs

Recent Posts

Airline tickets
S

You should be fine. I know that at least British Passports do not have the option to put Doctor on them anyway.

Supervisor as second author?
S

======= Date Modified 24 Jan 2012 13:46:30 =======

Quote From chococake:

Quote From screamingaddabs:

Yes you should. Everyone in academia knows that the first author is the one that did the work. Others just contributed a bit here and there, much like your sup.


Thanks. Everyone seems to have a different take on it. Which field are you in?


I'm in Engineering Science.

Edited to add: What possible harm is there in putting your sup as a second author? If the answer is that it won't do any harm at all (even if it doesn't add any benefit) then do it anyway and keep your sup on your side. I see no reason to not add their name. Everyone knows that you wrote the piece, it's just a nicety to add his/her name.

Supervisor as second author?
S

Yes you should. Everyone in academia knows that the first author is the one that did the work. Others just contributed a bit here and there, much like your sup.

OK, seriously, tell me...
S

Quote From badhaircut:



An easier option in academia is to become a lecturer or just a research fellow (though preferably on a permanent contract) and then not really aim to move any higher. Sure it'd be stressful to start with, but you'd soon get into the swing of doing enough to keep your job and having time off.


This is a massive oversimplification and overlooks several things. Fellows tend not to be on perm contracts for staters. Lecturers are part of a diminshing pool of labour and have more and more dumped on them as student numbers increase, administration goes up and the pressure to constantly publish keeps piling on.

Having left academia a while now, I work in the private sector at a comparable level and there is no where near the crap I had to put up with whilst as an academic. I have a perm post, I get paid according to my workload (more than uni rates) and my own time after 6pm is my own. I don't have to constantly watch for emails from students, mark essays or do the stuff at that is additional. Office politics and stress is everywhere but academia is on another level entirely.


But I'm sure there are people (like my supervisor at undergrad) for whom it works the other way. They had loads of shite to put up with in non-academia and have less as a lecturer. A lot will depend on the uni you're at and all sorts of other factors. I've found working at a uni less stressful than working in the "real world" so far (1.5 years into an RA post, spent 3 years in industry) and I reckon I do the same or fewer hours of work per week.

Basically it all just boils down to the specifics of one person in one job. On this board you will tend to get people who are going through a hard time because that's when they look for help, skewing how academia appears. Some people like their jobs some don't. Some people get over loaded in their jobs some don't etc etc. Academia or industry doesn't really come into it aside from short term contracts being more common in academia. Some people like that (don't get tied down), some hate it (job security etc).

All just my opinion of course, no peer reviewed research has gone into this :-)

Dr Bond!!
S

Well done Catalin, you should be very proud!

OK, seriously, tell me...
S

I still don't get this whole "academia is so different" thing. It's as if people here think that if you work in the private sector you don't have targets to meet and you don't work overtime.

How much time you put into a job depends on you. The academics you are comparing yourselves to tend to be professors yes? That's like comparing yourselves to a very highly paid executive. They also are stressed a lot etc.

Most jobs can be stressful, I would say that the only difference in academia is that the type of person who goes into academia *tends* to be fairly driven and focussed. Basically the type of person that gets stressed anyway. The question is basically why would anyone want to work really hard to get to the top of their field when they could take an easier option. Personally, I would take the easier option because I think there is more to life than my work. For many people their work is their passion, so they want to get to the top, which requires very hard work and is stressful. An easier option in academia is to become a lecturer or just a research fellow (though preferably on a permanent contract) and then not really aim to move any higher. Sure it'd be stressful to start with, but you'd soon get into the swing of doing enough to keep your job and having time off.

Have you always been a good student?
S

I guess I enjoyed school, mainly because I played rugby 6 days a week and the work was easy enough that I didn't have to try. Towards the end of A-levels I suddenly reached the stage at which I couldn't just breeze through though and so my marks dropped off and I had to learn how to actually apply myself. I then went to uni, studying engineering because I didn't know what I wanted to do and heard Engineers are pretty employable. First year was relatively easy as I had done further maths before and so I breezed through again, until 3/4 of the way through the year when I had to apply myself and didn't. I then drank heavily and had an awesome time for my second year and just scraped the passing mark for the year. That made third year hard as I essentially had to learn 2 years of stuff in one year due to not learning it the year before. By fourth year (I did an MEng) I finally actually applied myself and worked a bit and so I finished with a decent 2:1. I sometimes wonder how well I'd have done if I had tried throughout, but meh, I passed and had a great time. A few years in industry and I'm now back at Uni, working properly at academic stuff. It's definitely a lot easier when you try (not to say it is easy as such, just EASIER than it would be without the effort!). I always fancied doing a PhD but I kind of fell into it in the end as a means to an end.

So, in short:

- I liked school and was indifferent to learning (it was easy)
- When I was actually pushed I tended to just do badly
- I eventually learnt study skills and found it all a lot easier again

Pivotal thing that turned it round was that I actually HAD to try in my fourth year or I would have got a 2:2, which I would've found unacceptable.

Co-authors who have made minimal contributions
S

Yeah, I agree with the others who have commented. The most important thing by far is "who is the first author". People know that the first author is pretty much always the one who really did the work. Being a third or fourth author usually just means they supplied some data or something like that.

IPad or netbook?
S

You've answered your own question really. You love netbooks, you don't like touch screens and your only reservation is that they might not be as fast as an iPad? You can get them faster than an iPad. The only reason for getting an iPad is that it's a bit more shiny. Shiny thing make better?

I laughed when I saw the keyboard adaptor you can get for iPad style devices. That's basically a massively expensive net book with limited functionality that ties you to apple for the life of the product...

In summary: Get a netbook :-)

Another job offer - somewhere over the rainbow!
S

I see no reason to not go for it except fear of the unknown. That's not a great reason to turn it down in my opinion. Take the job. If you don't like it after a few months you are allowed to quit and go home. I bet that doesn't happen though.

It's understandable to be apprehensive of it, but you'll really regret it if you don't go. It's better to regret something you did than something that you didn't do. Plus Oz is a great place!

How much time do you take off around the holidays?
S

The uni is closed for nearly 2 weeks so I am taking 2 weeks off. I won't be doing any uni work because I don't ever do any outside of working hours. In general I use all of my 30 days off a year. Hell, they're there to use and there's way more to life than working.

Postdoc or research fellow/assistant
S

======= Date Modified 08 Dec 2011 09:28:33 =======
After the PhD i have found that Post doc positions tend to be called "Research Associate" as opposed to "Research Assistant" which is someone like me, doing research as full time employment before/during a PhD.

Edit: It doesn't help that they both abbreviate to RA!

need help fast
S

Have some faith! Go for gold!

I'd put 2012 personally as that is the year you will actually get your "dr" awarded.

First day of PhD, daunting!
S

I started my PhD last year in a field slightly removed from my original degree. The first thing I did was spend two months working from cover to cover through a text book about the new topic. It really helped me, so I'd suggest trying something similar. Find a book like "introductory whatever you want to learn" and go through it doing all the examples and everything. It's really boring, you feel like your wasting time, but when you've finished you realise how useful it actually was.

Starting to get desperate
S

Judging from these boards 7 months of looking is not a surprisingly long time, so don't get too down beat. People often struggle to find work after a PhD and if you haven't been well then this will have compounded the problem. Keep applying, remember you only need one yes!

As for interview tips, it sounds like you're already doing pretty well in the interviews - you've just been unlucky that someone they deem more experienced has been available.

You will sometimes (often!) find that jobs in universities are advertised when they already know who they want to work in that position - in some cases someone is already doing it. They have a legal obligation to advertise the position however. I know this because it was meant to happen for my job, which I was already doing. I was told they would have to interview people, but I was guaranteed the job. As it happens, for complicated reasons this didn't happen in this case, but I understand it is fairly common.

Maybe try to get some voluntary work experience in a relevant area whilst you look to try to make sure the gap on your CV doesn't grow too large. Other than that, good luck and try not to get too down about it.