Overview of TreeofLife

Recent Posts

Applying for a PhD
T

It totally varies depending on the project and your productivity levels. As a guide you should be looking at 15-20 hours a week.

As a student you don't pay council tax so that's one less thing for you to worry about!

2:2 BSc and MSc, should I not bother to apply to Oxbridge at all?
T

I would imagine you would struggle to compete for oxbridge places with a 2.2 even if you have a distinction for your MSc.

Is it a problem if some of your experiments use a different methodology to the others?
T

You will be fine as long as you can justify why the methods have been used or have been omitted.

Publishing with Supervisor, but Got Ditched!!!
T

I think we are confused as well because this person appears to be not from the UK, so when they are saying 'supervisor', they don't mean the UK version of a supervisor, but more someone from their thesis advisory committee.

Publishing with Supervisor, but Got Ditched!!!
T

Quote From Barramack:
Because he was a world renowned expert in their area of research?


Thank you Barramack, yes I read that.

Perhaps I should have asked a more direct question or two: Were your supervisors to be included on the paper, and if not, why not? And if they weren't, do you think that could be the issue?

question on Short Communication papers
T

My understanding is that whatever you are including in the paper, whether it's a whole study or a bit of it, you write it as a sort of report, so the methods, results and discussion are all together. I think what you include depends on the nature of the article.

Publishing with Supervisor, but Got Ditched!!!
T

Probably some internal politics somewhere. Why did you choose to publish with that person and not your supervisors?

Finally (almost) sumission
T
PhD and relationships
T

Quote From frere_damas:
[quote]
But also surely there's people who simply choose not to do a PhD because they find no fulfilment in it? I mean, can we really say that their potential is unfulfilled if they've chosen not do a PhD? My father chose not to go to university when he was young and he is one of the most intelligent and happy people I've ever met - hardly someone I'd refer to as unfulfilled potential.


I know not everyone has a desire to have a PhD. That's why I said 'or have a great job'. I could have said 'or learnt to paint/play the piano/speak French/climb Everest' or what ever else it is they wanted to do. I'm thinking about the many people I know that spend too much time drinking or taking drugs and have no job and when they do get a job they can't keep it because they are incapable of doing so because of the things that have happened in their lives. People that are far more intelligent than me. That is unfulfilled potential.

PhD and relationships
T

I think I said that having the opportunity to do a PhD indicates that someone has probably had a decent upbringing, meaning that there's many people who could do a PhD or have a great job but events in their life have meant that they haven't been able to fulfil their potential. I recognise that the reason I have achieved things in my life is because of the people I have been lucky to have in it - my parents, my family, teachers, managers, supervisors, friends, boyfriends.

I guess you think that I've never worked in retail, or as a cleaner, or as a waitress. Ok. I guess you think my PhD was handed to me on a plate. Ok. And apparently I put men off. Ok.

PhD and relationships
T

Quote From butterfly20:
I'm glad at least some people on here are not so judgemental!


Likewise! It's amazing the assumptions people make from a few forum posts.

PhD and relationships
T

At no point have I said I think I am better than others because I have a PhD. All I have said is that I like to surround myself with intelligent people - whether that's family members, friends or boyfriends. Generally, someone with a degree and someone with a PhD is likely to be more intelligent than someone without. That's it.

Of course I have many intelligent friends who don't have a degree and I have some not so intelligent friends with a PhD.

It's not like I go round asking everyone I met for a list of their qualifications before I consider talking to them. If you read my previous posts, I said I like nice, honest, decent people that I can have an intelligent conversation with. I didn't say I want to exclusively surround myself with people with PhDs because I think they are the only people worthy of my time.

PhD and relationships
T

I'm talking about when someone is doing a PhD at a university or working at a university, they are surrounded by academics.

For people with degrees, it's the same in the UK, 50% of people these days go to university. But, there may be 50% of people under 30 with a degree but that isn't 50% of the population as whole and it's not evenly spread across the country. So, if think of my family and friends from home, the percentage with a degree is more like 20%.

PhD and relationships
T

Quote From Dunham:
[quote]
It has been an immense privilege in the past. Nowadays, with a myriad of PhD students, it is not that much of a big deal as it was 50 years ago and it is also differently perceived by society. It is often just seen as an additional qualification like an MBA or sometimes just like a normal degree that consists of 3 instead of the usual 2 (bachelor + master) parts. People don't associate it with an exceptionally bright person anymore. This becomes especially clear if you compare the reactions of younger generations and elderly. While people like my grandma are still incredibly impressed by a PhD and see it as a huge accomplishment, most people in industry and almost all younger people with an academic degree value it far lower. "You are a chemist and have a PhD? Well, who hasn't?" Somehow like this, of course a bit dramatized ;) It is just not that special anymore and in many subjects like chemistry or physics you can pursue a PhD without having exceptional grades or outstanding merit. In many subjects like chemistry or biology it became a standard part of the education with far over 80% of graduates pursuing a PhD.

On the one hand, if you compare it to working class people that never saw a university from inside, it is of course still a privilege.


Yes, if you surround yourself with academics obviously it seems like no big deal to have a PhD as everyone has one, but that's what happens when one occupies that part of society. It becomes normalised. Reality is different. Less than 1% of the US population has a PhD and it's probably a similar figure elsewhere.

PhD and relationships
T

Quote From chickpea:
Interesting discussion..... One thing that struck me is that we all judge other people - it's not just about people with a PhD being perfectionists or whatever - I grew up in a working class area much like TreeofLife describes and I was judged to be a 'snob' because I was quiet and academic, and was excluded from pretty much everything. Over the years I have become friends with people in all sorts of jobs, but they have been imaginative, intelligent people and not narrow-minded like the people I grew up with - and thinking about it, they have all moved away from where they started and had different life experiences and education over the years.

I met my partner when I was 38, which was the right time for me as I'd figured out who I was and what was important to me, and I was in the right place to have a good relationship. Everyone's different in this respect, so I don't agree that waiting too long makes you a perfectionist or makes it more difficult to meet someone.


Thank you chickpea.