Overview of TreeofLife

Recent Posts

Girlfriend supervisor issues. Please give your advice.
T

Whilst technically the data belongs to the lab (she probably signed a intellectual property agreement), usually labs don't hold on to this when their students leave, because any publications should have the student and the supervisor as authors. This isn't a real policy though, and it's up to the supervisors what names are on the publications. Or up to your g/f if she decides to publish it regardless.

Also, unless she is changing her PhD topic, I don't see how she can get her PhD without the data, surely she won't be able to collect a extra year's worth of data without extending the duration of her PhD?

She should talk to the pastoral academics or the head of the graduate school for advice.

How long between acceptance, proofs, and online publication?
T

Mine was online less than a week after acceptance, and before the actual proofs were available. The proofs came about 2 weeks later I think.

I would email the editors if I were you.

Also depends on journal.

Accommodation: Halls or Studio?
T

Quote From KingInTheNorth:


International students can be interesting of course, though generally speaking from personal experience and those of my friends, they are usually quite quiet and keep to themselves unfortunately.


Ah ok, I guess some do. On reflection, about half of the international students in my lab keep to themselves and the others are fully integrated so I guess it depends on the individual and probably cultural background too.

Accommodation: Halls or Studio?
T

Personally I'd go with other postgrad students, but that's because I like a quieter social life. As a MSc student I didn't want to be out all hours or have people coming back and carrying on the party at 3pm - work was more important.

Also, I would appreciate being closer to the building I was working in. Also, international students can be interesting - lots of cultures to learn about!

Any tips?
T

Quote From Zutterfly:
Just to follow on from awsoci's point about revisions (and I know which post is being referred to here) the 'rounds' of feedback provided on chapters of your thesis is dependent on your supervisor. Yes, keep revising work; I have found a huge chunk of PhD time in the latter half is spent on revising, updating, editing and perfecting. Some supervisors will be happy to look at numerous versions of one chapter, whereas others may have preferences or rules for this. It is a good idea from the start to have a discussion with your supervisor about what both of your expectations are, as this can prevent problems later on.


Yes, and also, dependent upon subject area. It's not usual in hard sciences to keep revising writing. As long as the subject matter and terminology is correct, supervisors usually let you write how ever you like.

The first post-doctoral year without an academic post
T

only this
http://www.sciencemag.org/content/349/6244/206.short?rss=1&ssource=mfr

For the rest, looks like you are doing pretty well

Getting a first draft/refining chapters
T

My three data chapters don't overlap, so I polished as I went, and I didn't need to change anything later. I also didn't need to move information from main intro to chapter intros, but I think this is because I planned it effectively, so I knew what was going into each chapter.

Australian Uni PhD, got conflicted reports and ordered to r&r
T

I'm a bit confused. Are you saying you got an R&R, but you have the option of accepting it or not? What do you mean you can defend it? What does your supervisor say?

Starting PhD after 4 years of job
T

Hi ricki, I was in exactly the same position as you 4 years ago when I started my PhD. It was a massive learning curve coming back to science after a 5 year break, but don't worry, I'm proof it can be done as I submitted my thesis a couple of weeks ago!

My advice would be recognise that the first week is going to be very difficult and then you will have peaks and troughs as you go through. Don't let your supervisors know how inexperienced you are - give them a good first impression! Do ask for help from the other people in the lab though. My supervisors just handed me a protocol and told me to do it. There was no way I could - I had no idea what any of it meant. I just asked the people in the lab to help me, and then when I did it, I went to the supervisor with the result and told them so and so helped me. They were fine with that, what they wouldn't have liked was if I didn't show any initiative - if I had told them I couldn't do, or asked them for help, or just didn't do it.

You will fine that everyone knows more than you. You will make stupid mistakes. You will look back in a few months/years time and think 'what an idiot I was'. This is all totally normal.

On the plus side, you have research experience, so you won't need to ask how to pour an agar plate or how to calculate a 1 M solution, like I did. Good luck and I hope you enjoy it!

Accepting PhD Offer
T

Congrats Alanine!

Are you starting in October? If so, you might not hear anything else until Sept. After my informal offer of a place, I had to log on to the uni system to accept it 2 weeks later, and then I didn't hear anything for another 2 to 3 months, which was in Sept, before I started in Oct.

When did you format your thesis?
T

We don't have a default at uni so I just used Calibri

When did you format your thesis?
T

Quote From Barramack:
Formatting your chapters in Word will not be a worry once you have set up your styles (e.g. heading hierarchy and main text).


Exactly, that's what I meant. Learn to format it before you start, then you don't need to worry about it. It's so much easier when your tables and heading renumber themselves and make tables of contents for you etc

what would you do ?
T

40 mile away

When did you format your thesis?
T

I'd do it correctly as you do it. The last thing you want to do is think you have finished your thesis and then realise that formatting takes days and days...

Also, I liked to have it positioned on the page as it would be in the final version, so that's another reason why I formatted as I wrote.

Unemployed :(
T

Quote From Dunham:
Quote From TreeofLife:


It's not human to think like that at all. It's an option to think like that, but you don't have to. If I end up working for minimum wage for the rest of my life I will still never regret my PhD. Everyone is different. Personally I find it better to think of things as a positive experience than get bitter about them. I would expect that makes for a happier life.


We sometimes do not choose how we feel about certain things. How great would it be if people could just tell themselves to be positive about a certain thing and then it is like that. That's not how it works. .


True, I guess not everyone can choose their perspective on things.