Overview of TreeofLife

Recent Posts

Finding the right University, supervisor or funding - which is key?
T

What field are you in? If it's science, you usually just apply to funded projects, and the university does matter. You should aim for at least a Redbrick. It doesn't really matter about location, you need to narrow the choice down somehow anyway.

Paid Proof-reading - how to do it well.
T

I don't take money for proof reading for my friends either but some other people in my lab do and that's up to them. I don't think it's anyone's place to comment on the actions of others regarding proofreading payments.

Don't want to sound dumb but I need advice for PhD
T

It sounds like you are underestimating yourself. If your supervisor thinks you are good enough to do a PhD you probably are. Now you just need to decide whether you want to do one or not. And we all feel like we know nothing, and that feeling is often exacerbated when doing a PhD, so be prepared for that.

Am I supposed to be available whenever my supervisors decide is convenient for a meeting?
T

I will usually attend meetings at whatever time they ask, but if I see them starting an email chain about a day I can't do, I just stop them right away and suggest another date. They don't mind I can't make the meetings on the day they choose anyway.

Dr Marasp!
T

Well done Marasp! Your hard work paid off!

R &R Trust issues with supervisor- need honest answers, but don't know how to ask
T

Quote From Ganesha:
Hi PhdDefault
I think I should have asked for an explanation as to why they thought they could not supervise me anymore. I did not know I could have done that-another problem of being an international student and being vulnerable and easily taken advantage of as I don't know my rights-as if I have any.


How do you think home students know their rights? They find them out. They read the information provided on the school website. They listen in the introductory seminars and they read the handouts given during induction. They talk to other students. Not knowing is not an excuse.


Quote From Ganesha:

However, I don't think it matters to them as it does to me if I fail even after R & R. How does it matter? Who cares?


Of course it doesn't matter as much to them as it matters to you, it's your PhD not theirs.

R&R is not the end of the world and it happens to a lot of people. Just make the corrections and I'm sure you will be fine.

R &R Trust issues with supervisor- need honest answers, but don't know how to ask
T

Quote From Ganesha:
Treeoflife-

no...the supervisors can give extension and the international student can then apply for more time from the university and subsequently the home office will then have to give visa extension to International students based on what the university has been told by the supervisors. My uni' immigration office told me that at this stage, I can get indefinite extension with the support of my supervisors. In my case, my supervisors said they CANNOT SUPERVISE ME ANYMORE. that was the end of the matter, I cannot argue. If I were a local student, surely I would have got support indefinitely and not be forced into submitting a trash thesis. If they wanted to, they could have supported me and given at least three more months-that's all I needed.


This has got nothing to do with the fact you are an international student. If I asked my supervisors for an extension I would get the same answer, even though I am entitled to an extension if I have extenuating circumstances, just like you.

R &R Trust issues with supervisor- need honest answers, but don't know how to ask
T

Or maybe it's because your funding and visa will run out and they wanted to ensure you would finish before then, knowing that UK students can often get funding from parents or partner to finish?

All the international students I know are encouraged to submit by 3.5 years so that they should have 6 months of extra funding whilst waiting for viva and corrections. Actually UK students are too, but most don't, and then end up working for an extra year without funding. This is not discrimination. This is sensible planning on the supervisors' part for the international students.

And honestly speaking, 9/13 students in my lab are international students, and some of these people are my closest friends, but they are not competitors to me... they are not even close.

Obviously supervisors take on international students for the money, and maybe they are due it, because most are a lot of extra work in comparison to UK students. For instance, I have spent 6 hours working on a Sunday when I really didn't want to be working today, and 3 of those hours were spent reviewing a thesis introduction for one of my international friends. It probably would have taken me an hour if it was a British student.

R &R Trust issues with supervisor- need honest answers, but don't know how to ask
T

Quote From Ganesha:
Infact, in many ways, he got me into this because of the section on ethics! My supervisors did not alert me at all to anonymize my informants something that they were reading for the last two years since I was writing! If only they had warned me I would had a different outcome. Of course, I anonymized some bits like location of my research because I have like 40 informants in my thesis-it was impossible to anonymize all of them and I totally missed it while writing up but that it's why supervisors should do their jobs-pick up on less obvious things. Ahhh....drives me mad. The examiner made a big thing out of this. Thanking my stars that day I did not fail outright. In any case, I had submitted in a rush as well. No rest.....straight 18 months after fieldwork and submitted it!


Sounds like you need to take some responsibility as well if you ask me.

I want to impress people and be the best
T

Quote From Ganesha:
You are facing the same problem I faced- being dumbed down by the Phd supervision process and the hassle of arranging both supervisors to read your drafts and such. The major problem of doing Phd is to accept how litte there is any intellectual component. If anything,
Unfortunately, this academic pace is what cripples intellectualism becaue some students are ahead of their supervisors like it happens for most international students like myself as we face immigration and visa problems making us more focussed and more ambitious than local students.


The hassle of having supervisors check your work... supervisors who have probably been in the field for 10 - 30 years and you think they don't know better than you

I wouldn't say most international students are ahead of their supervisors. Far from it.

I wouldn't say that international students are more focused and more ambitious either. I think all students are. If anything, international students have it easier in terms of job prospects.because many of them have academic jobs to return to at home, or that are very easy to get for people with PhDs,

Present for Supervisor - When Submitting or After Viva?
T

Someone in my lab didn't get on with our supervisors and did just that - they didn't bother giving them anything. I don't think it matters either way, if they had given them something, they would have know it was disingenuous anyway

"List of recommended universities"
T

I think most professors like to pursue their own agendas, so in many cases you are better just applying to an advertised project and keeping your ideas to yourself...

Publish and Perish blogpost
T

Love how my supervisor has already retweeted that haha!

Supervisor Contact Help/ Proposal without supervisor's help
T

So they haven't agreed to supervise your project yet? I assume they have no reason to talk to you then. You will have to just apply to the school and see if you get accepted.

Dissertation Title: PROBLEM OF INADEQUATE PARKING SPACES IN PUBLIC BUILDINGS IN UYO METROPOLIS
T

I heard google is a great tool for searching for papers.