Overview of TreeofLife

Recent Posts

Husband and wife joining a PhD program with a plan for baby?
T

Quote From Trilla:
PNV, unless you are at the end of your biological clock I'd advise against the PhD and baby. I did mine with teen kids and a job, did it in 3 years on the dot but, boy, it was the hardest thing I have done. I have aged 10 years in these 3...And that's 3 years of my kids' life I'll never get back. i think that doing the two you won't enjoy neither the phd or parenthood.


I agree with this. Three of my friends have had a baby whilst doing a lab-based PhD and all of them wished in some way or another they didn't. For some it was planned without fully appreciating the consequences, for others it was unplanned. If there's no rush to start a family, then just wait it out. It's only three years. A PhD is a big enough commitment without a baby as well.

Having said that, none of my friends had their mother in laws around, in fact in two out of the three cases, the mother went back to work one month after giving birth and the father was the care giver (he wasn't doing a PhD or working). In the other case, the mother wasn't doing a PhD and the father was 6 months from finishing the thesis.

I am biggest idiot ever , is there hope I will be still contacted by the university?
T

Well done! Good to see you were worrying over nothing :P

Will some universities only reply to your application if they have accept it ?
T

That sounds like they will contact you either way. But I wouldn't put too much on the dates they give. Academics are notorious for not sticking to deadlines. It took me two months after the closing date to hear back from some posts I have applied for. You've just got to wait it out and keep applying for other stuff in the meantime.

Job roles in academia - what do they entail?
T

Hi, yes the titles vary across countries. The US uses totally different titles for example e.g. anyone who teaches is a professor (assistant prof., associate prof.), whereas in the UK these are the lecturer/senior lecturer roles.

The titles can also vary within the UK. Also role responsibilities and staff benefits and pay will vary across institutions e.g. I note in the link you posted it said post doc fellows are staff, well so are all those positions under it in my institution.

I don't know of any specific links, I've just seen this stuff on individual university websites when looking for information when applying for jobs. Basically, you need to check each one when applying as a research associate in one isn't a research associate in another and the pay and grade can vary. And then of course regardless of what a job advert or university guidelines say, the PI can just make up their own rules when you start the job - there may be no official working hours, but they try to stipulate them, or you find out that no one follows the HR guidelines anyway etc.

ICYMI: The Case for Colonialism
T

Thanks for the additional insight Trilla. Has anyone seen any communication from the author about this paper since? Are they a respected academic or just a random person with an academic job?

Stress and anxiety while waiting for PhD viva
T

You can apply for postdocs whilst waiting for your viva. Looking for postdocs is what most people are doing in between thesis submission and viva... that and writing papers.

Another Masters from the same Level7 but differetn subject area -international student
T

1) Yes, I don't see why not, unless there's funding restrictions. There shouldn't be visa or uni restrictions on this.

2) Zero? I don't think you pay until just before you start

conflict of interest with a member of editorial board
T

If that person is an editorial member of most relevant publications then you are going to have the same issue wherever you publish. Just write to the editor and say that that person has a potential conflict of interest (nothing else) and request that someone else is the associate editor and chooses the reviewers. This is probably a question you will be asked upon submission to the journal anyway.

Stubborn supervisor
T

Quote From Esca:
Thank you very much for your detailed response. I am not saying " I am right" - I just feel I need to search the literature to back up his ideas but the literature doesn't... I told him in a nice way but he is stubborn and laughs it off. He is very nice but it makes me feel I have to find what he wants me to find..


You're unlikely to win with these type of people. If I pushed my supervisor on this he would say 'go ahead, do it with 7, but when your paper gets rejected or you get a revise and resubmit on your PhD, you know who to blame'.

Sometimes it's easier just to go along with what they say; pick your battles carefully. I've found it's better to keep them sweet in order to reap future benefits of their advice/connections/whatever than start annoying them and souring the relationship.

Like pm133 said, you will likely have other opportunities to go your own way later in the PhD.

The irony of the word 'student'
T

According to universities, anyone doing a BSc, MSc or PhD is a student in the UK. These people do not have contracts of employment, so they are not employees. We are all called students at my uni - usually "undergrads" and "postgrads". Postdocs on the other hand, are not students, they are employees. They may be trainees, but they are not students.

The hierarchy of knowledge is obvious once you make the transition - of course I know more than undergrads and MSc/PhD students about my particular field now, so it's easy to think of them as students with a lot to learn, after all, I spend a lot of time training and advising them. I'm sure my former PhD supervisors think the same about me and about their postdocs and junior colleagues. When I think back to how little I knew in the first year of my PhD compared to now...

This is a useful infographic:
http://www.labspaces.net/blog/1444/How_people_in_science_see_each_other_

Not-to-be-mentioned-option post-PhD
T

Quote From iwan:
Do people tend to judge if a PhD candidate mention that upon graduation, he/she is aiming for a teaching position in polytechnics? I often get that 'why do you aim so low' or 'why do you even choose to do a PhD even'.

is this thought about career option not something to be shared amongsts your coursemates?


Oh absolutely. Don't you know that the only respectable academic career is the traditional lectureship, with as little teaching as possible?

In fact, in a conversation with a professor the other day, we were talking about who was leading undergraduate workshops and she said "Not academics surely? Oh no, it's teaching staff." We may be on academic contracts, some of us permanent ones, but we will always be inferior to traditional lecturers in their eyes.

ICYMI: The Case for Colonialism
T

I only have a layperson's grasp of this subject matter, but I do believe in academic freedom of thought and writing. I see nothing wrong with this publication as one academic's take on the matter. Others are free to rebut it.

does a 3rd class degree matter in the creative industries?
T

It's possible, but of course harder. I don't know specifically about creative industries. I would suggest networking to find a way in if possible, as it will be easier to overlook a 3rd on paper than if someone knows you.

At a crossroads- Do the PhD or not?
T

This might differ in different countries. In the UK, a research assistant post is usually for someone without a PhD. It's like a technician. Then research associate is for someone with a PhD - it's a first postdoc. Sometimes people work full or pt as a research assistant and do a PhD full or pt but this is fairly rare.

MPA programs - Online
T

Most people on here are either studying in the UK or from the UK so you might not get many responses.

I'd say start with the rest of your cohort - it's always easier.