Overview of tru

Recent Posts

Searching for postdocs
T
Dropping out of PhD - what's next?
T

Hi, nordsee,

Take two weeks off and have a think about if you want that PhD or not. If you don't need that PhD (aka you don't want to go into academia), I would suggest that you consider doing something else since you are paying for it.

Doing a PhD is different from a BSc or MSc. You work on a single project in depth whereas in BSc and even MSc (not MRes), they are coursework based and each course is for a short period of time. If you are a person who likes constant change and excitement, a PhD is definitely not for you.

Go have a look at jobs that have constantly changing work environment. Eg. sales rep, field scientist, application specialist, environmentalist, marine biologist/forest ranger, etc

To continue Phd or not
T

I agree with Tudor_Queen...

If the environment is toxic which is your case, staying is just prolonging your sufferring. Change supervisor if you can. As someone who survived an extremely toxic lab environment and PhD, I strongly advise you to leave that lab and change supervisor while you still have your sanity intact.

It is not a sign of weakness to change supervisor and project. It is a sign that you care enough to give yourself another chance to get the best possible chance at succeeding at your PhD.

All the best.

Is it okay to expect advisor(s) to offer a word of condolence?
T

Hi, Karmah,

I am so sorry for your loss. Do get some free counselling at uni if you need it... Time will heal you...

The question you could ask is: Is the person a human?
If answer is yes, then yes, we should expect a word of condolence.
If answer is no, then no, no such expectation....

Seeking employment post-PhD dropout (stating reasons)
T

Quote From iwan

The civil service sector that i am considering to work under deals with pesticide management regulations and it involves some research and analyses as well. Is this considered an industry in itself?


I consider industry = non academia. So yeah, yours sound like industry.

'Off' Days
T

We are humans, not robots. Have your break, however long it takes to refresh, then get back to your PhD with high motivation and good spirits

How do I bulk up my CV for the next round of PhD applications?
T

If you are targeting for a funded position, you may find that you are competing against those with better academic results, eg. First class honour in BSc and Distinction in masters. Therefore, you may face challenges to get in.

You may wish to consider interning or working as a RA/technician in the lab or field that you are interested in to build relationship and gain skills that are valuable for your PhD. Thay may be your trump card to overcome your challenges of other candidates with better academic achievements.

After horrible 5.5 years completely failed PhD (not even any degree awarded)
T

Quote From Tigernore:
Hi,

I know of multiple students having had ...let's say issues in my department. Including sexual harrassment and when filed being threatened with losing the degree, having no right to holidays and having the same issue I have of being told to go part-time (including part-time stipend) but working full-time in the lab-which most cannot afford.

I just can't seem to get heard, everyone is just saying, well let it go they have the power etc. And without access to labs like you agree I can't get anywhere and I don't even have a supervisor / academic tutor at this point.

I am filing my appeal over this week and requesting await of the complaint process and readjustment of my access. It is impossible to salvage this into a PhD with what happened but at least an MPhil would have been nice.

Thanks for your messages!!!


Ah, the usual discouragement.. "Let go because you can't win.. Why bother since your supervisors have power..." Haven't we all heard of that before... This is the phsycological game to break the student's spirit and rid "troublemakers".. Don't give in.

Tigernore, steel yourself. You have not been given a fair fighting chance, and you know it. Instead of talking to nonsense people who are out to discourage you (probably other academics who may or may not have ties with your uni and supervisor), talk to your Student Union who is supposed to defend you. Talk to a legal representative from your Student Union. Fight for your PhD... All is not lost unless you give up on yourself. All the best in your appeal, and don't walk away without exhausting all avenues.

Seeking employment post-PhD dropout (stating reasons)
T

Great that you are ok and having job offers.

However, it is NEVER ok for companies to ask for your recent pay slips. This is inappropriate, and the only reason they ask for this is to see the lowest salary they can offer you based on your previous pay. Never give this info. They could have asked for reference as proof of employment instead of payslip. If they insist on pay slip, think twice whether the company with such awful work ettique is the right one for you.

Why did you leave your PhD? Well, you could say that you realised that PhD wasn't for you, that you didn't want to have a career in academia any longer and wanted to work in the industry. So you decided to cut your losses and leave your PhD. My friend answered that after leaving her PhD, got a job with a mega firm, and has never looked back since.

After horrible 5.5 years completely failed PhD (not even any degree awarded)
T

Hi, Tigernore,

You have my sympathy. Working under a bullly supervisor is awful and you have not been given fair treatment.

As Tree of Life has advised, seek the Students Union. In fact, see if your Students Union provide legal services. You have nothing to lose anyway, and talking to a lawyer will help you determine if any rules have been broken incl the right access to lab support and material as a student. It will also put pressure on the university as they normally do not want anything that may damage their reputation, especially if they are in the wrong. You may even be able to fight for lab access again and another fair examination of your thesis.

Dry your tears. Now is the time for desperate actions and strategy. You must stay strong. What your supervisor and examiners want to do is to force you to give up and walk away, painting you as a bad student. You must not let them win. I speak from my personal experience as I too launched a complain towards my supervisor and the amount of backlash and soft threats (veiled as advice to maintain good relationship with supervisor as I need his letter of support) were terrible. I represented myself at institute level -failed, faculty level -failed and finally University level -success with a detailed portfolio of evidence and cover letter provided with strong support from a lawyer from Students Union. In my case, I had very strong evidence and was advised by my lawyer that if I failed again at university level, I could go to court. Luckily I didn't have to but the experience was traumatic. Every case is different, and I wish you the very best as you fight for yours. Don give up without trying to fight.

Clarity needed - supervisor on leave (still)
T

How irresponsible, to not get you a second supervisor while she is on maternity leave. Would you consider changing project and supervisor completely? Your supervisor has not guided you properly and is very inexperienced (first time supervisor), plus you have no idea when she is coming back. Don waste time. Talk to your Grad School or overall postgrad coordinator. Have a look around for more experienced and responsible supervisor. Talk to students of supervisors you are interested in. Changing supervisor is not a sign of complain or weakness. Quite the opposite, you are strong enough to find s solution to a problem and willing to try again. Don let her false promises of "things will get better" and "you have to be loyal to me" hold you back, if she does throw them at you.

Try for PhD or a Second MS
T

Calculation of overall average should be total of (weightage x marks of all subjects) divided by total number of credits. So, if you took two subjects and got 75% for a 20 credit course and 50% for a 30 credit course, your average will be [(75*20) + (50*30)] / (20 + 30) = 60%. In other words, if you score really badly in a high weightage subject, you will end up with poor score.

Supervisor Dilemma and Competency Issues
T

If A is going to be a serious hindrance to your PhD, then action may need to be taken. Can you change your primary to B? Check with your Grad School. If given the ok, approach B to confirm then fill in d necessary form. I would also consider getting rid of A completely if this person will be doing continuous damage to you because he is upset with the change and insult. We are all human, and some people take things very personally.

PhD candidate withdrawal process
T

No one can make you stay if you don want to. Pretty sure you have to fill in a form from Grad School. Do that and you should be done

Quitting PhD
T

You have already made up your mind.... just follow it through despite the backlash you may receive