Overview of AcademicsAnonymous

Recent Posts

Over 2 weeks to assign reviewers?
A

Phew, it's 'Awaiting Reviewer Scores' now, problem solved :) I think it must have just been the time of year.

Over 2 weeks to assign reviewers?
A

Hi all,

Thanks for your responses. Thanks for the reassurance that this is normal.

I'm in the social sciences. I've been advised by others to expect a 3 month review cycle.

I did notice that whereas the 'elite' journal that was previously more speedy had a separate admin not on the editorial team, the editors in this case are also the admins. Perhaps that's what's slowing things down.

I would hope people are not refusing to review it. I have suggested a few relevant reviewer (they enable you to do this), and it is a very interesting contemporary topic! Although I am biased ;)

It is just annoying as I rushed to get the paper in, only to see it sitting there!

Over 2 weeks to assign reviewers?
A

Hi all. I recently submitted a paper to a 'B' journal in my field (good, but not one of the elites). I had told the editor I was planning to submit about 2 weeks before (I know her slightly, and had asked something about formatting). However I submitted on the 16th September, and the paper still shows 'Awaiting Reviewer Assignment'. This seems very slow and inefficient- to leave the paper sitting there for two weeks, gathering dust? In the past it has usually taken a few days, a week maximum (even at elite journals). Does anyone have similar experiences?