Close Home Forum Sign up / Log in

Examiner excessive delay in marking

D

I submitted my PhD 8 months ago and am still waiting on the result. I have two external examiners who apparently cannot agree on whether it is good enough. I sent it off for external review and they came back with a 'good pass'. I was not happy with not having anyone from my university as examiner. I am getting no information from the university registry and very little from my supervisor. Any suggestions as to what I can do?

I

My situation isn't exactly like yours but I passed with minor corrections, which I submitted a month after the viva but it took my internal 6 months to come back to me approving them. The best thing to do is to keep in touch with the examiners themselves directly. If they came back with a good pass shouldn't the registry just approve you?! Sounds strange- or do you need the two external examiners' approval as well?

B

I have no idea what the OP means by external review (some random person you paid to check it?), but normally two external examiners are required if the OP is a university employee or there's a similar reason why an internal examiner might be deemed to be prejudiced in favour or against the candidate.
I'd make a written complaint about the excessive delays to the dean of research students / graduate school / whoever centrally is responsible for overseeing the examination process. Ask for a clear timeline for a decision - they owe you that much. It would be worth looking at any handbook / regulations you have - there may be a set time period given and I'd imagine 8 months is way over that. If you can get the person in your school who is responsible for research students to complain on your behalf that might be more effective.

29450