Close Home Forum Sign up / Log in

Journal article submission

S

I've submitted an article a while ago and it came back with 'in need of revisions'. I'm working on these as we speak and I'm just wondering how many times can it go back and forth before they ultimately reject it? Is this my only chance with this journal?

I think its quite common for you to get a second R&R from a journal, so you get another chance. BUt I've heard people get 2 R&Rs and then a rejection which must be extremely annoying, particularly if you'd revised it specifically for the way the journal wanted it which may not be relevant to other journals.

T

Quote From sneaks:

I think its quite common for you to get a second R&R from a journal, so you get another chance. BUt I've heard people get 2 R&Rs and then a rejection which must be extremely annoying, particularly if you'd revised it specifically for the way the journal wanted it which may not be relevant to other journals.


wow; that can happen?

I'm waiting for my paper to be published; the place that I sent stated that they would notify me on X date, and it has been weeks now and no notifications :/

S

I'm glad to hear that Sneaks. After lots of rejigging and re-structuring, I've come to the conclusion that their revisions will require me to make some significant changes. I don't mind the changes, but they haven't given me very clear instructions, apart from 'that needs more info' sort of thing so it's hard to know if what I'm doing is what they want me to do and I'd be very upset if they just went 'nah, still not good enough'. Hopefully I won't get a rejection then.

Tt_dan - personally, I wouldn't worry about that too much. They'll let you know either way at some point and submitting a paper isn't the speediest thing ever, especially if they're depending on others to review it!

tt_dan, I'd chase it if its gone beyond the time they set you. Chances are its got lost or stuck with a reviewer they need to chase.

D

Quote From sneaks:

I think its quite common for you to get a second R&R from a journal, so you get another chance. BUt I've heard people get 2 R&Rs and then a rejection which must be extremely annoying, particularly if you'd revised it specifically for the way the journal wanted it which may not be relevant to other journals.

I have to say that baffles me - if they've asked for revisions, that implies that the article would be suitable if those revisions were made. I did some revisions then got the article rejected, which certainly was annoying! Plus the journal involved, the Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, took an inordinate amount of time to get back to me. It was over a year from first submission before they finally sent me a rejection.

22854