Am I old-fashioned? I was always told that prospective PhD students with industrial experience are valued by admissions selectors because of their maturity, and because of the lesser likelihood that they're wanting to do a PhD on a whim (and there does seem to be a number of such people). It seems from reading some of the messages on this forum though that this doesn't apply anymore. Maybe I'm wrong, but if anything, given the strong competition for funded PhD places, having industrial experience would be something that is more desirable to have than before.