Hi,

A supervisor who is always there and interested in his lab is a millions times much better than an aloof one. You most probably get great direction on your work. It may seem difficult at times but being micromanaged during your PhD is the best thing. You will always know where you stand and will learn a lot. Guidance is very important during this time.
I wish I were in a lab where I could recieve guidance instead of going around in circles not knowing where my theis is heading.
I hope this helps. But try rotating if you are unconfortable and let us know what you decide!
Good luck.