At what point in your PhD did you know what you were really doing?

S

I've been doing my PhD for about six weeks now. I still have no idea what I'm really doing, I'm just reading into a very broad topic. Is this normal? My reading can also be a day reading a 4/5 page paper and understanding only 80% of 3 key points. I feel I should at least know what problem I'll be working toward solving by now.

When do you start to know what you're doing?

C

I did a lot of reading at the start too, trying to find a gap in the literature as well as trying to understand the field better. Even when I did have research questions and a proposal, they changed over time. I wouldn't worry too much at the six-week stage - just keep talking to your supervisor about your ideas.

B

There's no right or wrong point at which things click into place. As chickpea said, your research question changes over time and even after data collection/analysis. My advice is to just keep writing your ideas. Write everything that comes to mind no matter how big or small it might seem.

I started my PhD with a very specific idea about what I wanted to research and how I was going to go about it (for the funding application), and it has changed completely since then. Nature of research! :)

P

I didn't know properly at least until I scraped through my first upgrade, so probably not til early year 2. In year 1 I read, and wrote, some rubbish. But keep all that rubbish, might come in useful one day.

C

From the start I knew what I wanted to do. That changed when those experiments went to a bit of a dead end, got parcelled up as a 'negative result' chapter. Took about a year to figure out what I'd do from there. But that year involved a lot of valuable troubleshooting and thinking.

H

1 year and 4 months into the PhD. That is when I submitted a proposal to ethics too. In hindsight, it should have all been sorted much earlier.

T

Not at least until the 2nd year (part-time). And even then there were periods when I went off track and lost what I was doing, then had to try and find it again. It's a natural and normal part of the process. My PhD project 6 weeks in was radically different from my submitted thesis.

43965