Hi everyone,
Your thoughts and experiences please.
I recently had my Viva and thought I performed well. I answered all the questions posed by the examiners and was not told that anything crucial was missing from my thesis. My methodology was not criticized nor was my literature review, my research questions or the originality of my work.
Yet I came out of the exam with a revise and resubmit, with a second viva and a change in supervision.
There was no negotiation about what needed to change and a time frame within which to complete was not proposed.
From the examiners' reports, I gathered they didn't like my writing style but did not question much in terms of content.
Can anyone help me to understand this result? Has anyone had a similar experience?
Yours in confusion,
Doodle Berry
Sorry to hear that, sounds like a fairly odd viva. Generally it should be pretty obvious as you go through what they think the 'holes' in your thesis are.
What does your supervisor think? Is there any grounds to appeal?
Doodle Berry, really sorry to learn of your result. Did your supervisor not say anything to you after the result was given? Some form of debrief or discussion? Surely after being given an R & R (with viva) you would be entitled to ask some questions and talk it over?
Are you up to being persistent with making contact with your supervisor? By this I mean, it is a tough blow (by no means meaning you won't be able to overcome this and pass this after some work) and sometimes instinct in these cases is to curl up in a ball rather than ask legitimate questions of the person who took you up to this point and signed you off on submission.
Hello again everyone,
I've spent the last week or two trying to get satisfactory answers out of my supervisor (whose middle name is "Big mouth"!) and have received none.
Is there anything to be gained switching supervisor for the remaining tenure of my R&R?
How does one call prejudice on examiners?
Are both of the above fatal mistakes?
Still in confusion...
It is important that you are offered a list of revisions and time frame for the revision. Otherwise in your second round examination you are still facing the danger of fail.
It's highly unlikely you will be able to switch supervisors at this stage, since you are now post submission and what happens next is between you and your examiners. I would go and see the head of graduate school or similar and see what they suggest.
I don't have a list of corrections yet which is part of the problem as I still see no justification for the R&R.
As an examiner, I thought one as to turn up to the exam with no set result in mind? I thought that if you do turn up and do not give the candidate a chance to argue you turn, that in a sense is prejudicial? I didn't even get the opportunity to discuss time frame for the changes that are apparently needed. Frankly, I feel as though this examiner has no intention of ever passing me.
My supervisor and this examiner apparently have a fraught relationship.
Surrounding the administration of the examination, there were a couple of things that went amiss. My supervisor has been a terrible administrator and I have suffered at every turn because of it. This is perhaps why I am in the muddle I find myself now. I would like to be protected by someone going forward and it can't get worse than it already is.
As no timeframe is ticking away yet as such, I feel I do have time to change supervisors?
PostgraduateForum Is a trading name of FindAUniversity Ltd
FindAUniversity Ltd, 77 Sidney St, Sheffield, S1 4RG, UK. Tel +44 (0) 114 268 4940 Fax: +44 (0) 114 268 5766
An active and supportive community.
Support and advice from your peers.
Your postgraduate questions answered.
Use your experience to help others.
Enter your email address below to get started with your forum account
Enter your username below to login to your account
An email has been sent to your email account along with instructions on how to reset your password. If you do not recieve your email, or have any futher problems accessing your account, then please contact our customer support.
or continue as guest
To ensure all features on our website work properly, your computer, tablet or mobile needs to accept cookies. Our cookies don’t store your personal information, but provide us with anonymous information about use of the website and help us recognise you so we can offer you services more relevant to you. For more information please read our privacy policy
Agree Agree