Overview of vivicov

Recent Posts

Rapid advice needed on Viva
V

For my viva, my head of department sit through the process himself, to make sure "I am treated nicely". I do think he brought me some advantages, but I'm not sure if it is only my feeling.

They did not let me choose to have him sit in or not,on the day of my viva the head of department just told me "I will be there to make sure they are kind to you, otherwise I will punch them in the face". Haha!!

Usually supervisors are not allowed in the viva? At least in my university it is not possible to have your supervisor there.

I passed my viva... and you will
V

Hi Tanumahuta:
I did experience loads of self-doubt, the situation got so serious that I could only discuss my thesis with my supervisor, who was the only one read it completely. When every other single person (friends, families..) mentioned it, I would just want to hide and change the subject. That was how bad I felt about my thesis.

I did most of my work in the last 3 months to be honest...I guess it is kind of normal....

Its gonna be over soon! Good Luck :)

I passed my viva... and you will
V

Hi Everyone:
Thank you all !!!
Today I received an email from the external examiner, inviting me to present a paper in a workshop she is starting to organize. I am quite happy because the external examiner is a scholar that I really admire !

About my viva experience, it was unbelievably straightforward to be honest.
It lasted only for one hour, and our head of department sit in throughout the process, "to make sure the examiners treat me nicely". Internal examiner started by asking the reason of doing this research, and then both examiners ask me to clarify some arguments. They did not mention any minor things like typos, or even specific details in my thesis.THEY DO NOT CARE THESE THINGS AT ALL even though they did give me a list of things that they spotted. All they ask was the big picture, the main argument. After they felt that they were persuaded by my explanations, the viva ended.

At the end of the viva they also mentioned some problems in my thesis as, and I did not strongly defend myself and admit that I did struggle at some details and I am aware that a PhD thesis cannot be perfect. And it seems they are fine with my honesty!

Help - what do I do?
V

Hi echo_85:

I agree with psychresearcher, don't feel bad about taking an extension. I took three-month extension which was so important to me, since I put everything together in those three months. Having an extension turned out to be one of the best decisions I have made for my Phd. Even if it only gives you some breathing space, it is good enough. Health always come first. If you really need it, discuss it with your supervisor. Its fine and you are really close to the end:)

Regarding to your progress, I think it is much better than many people (certainly including me). It is normal to shape the introduction in the end because you know what elements really needs to be covered now. Revisions to chapters wont take that much time but indeed takes more concentration, 7 weeks is doable, but if you feel too stressed about it, its actually very good to have some more time.

I passed my viva... and you will
V

So what I want to say is....if I can pass it, I am sure everyone here has no problem of reaching this goal.... I really hated my own thesis, questioning myself all the time, feeling like an imposter (and I still do, I was wondering that the examiners were too nice to me....)

But before the viva, I just told myself I gotta give myself some confidence, after all, at this stage, it doesn't hurt to act as confidently as possible.

For anyone who thinks they cannot finish, please give it a try!!! :))
Thanks for every one who had kindly provided me suggestions and encouragements.
Its such a blessing to find this place, to feel not alone.

I passed my viva... and you will
V

Hi everyone:

I just passed my PhD viva today, some minor corrections to finish in one month.
The Viva only lasted for an hour, and the examiners were satisfied enough to stop questioning me.

Like many people on this forum have said…I never imagined I can come this far. I thought I would stuck in this PhD black hole for ever and ever…and if you feel like this as well, you have to know that it will really end…someday…

I am actually new to the forum, because I didn't join this place until the last stage of my PhD. It was two weeks before my submission, I felt depressed and was really disappointed at the quality of my thesis. I did so many last-minute improvements that drove me crazy. Then I found this forum through Google, read lost of posts, and find some strength to keep going.

I have to admit that I am still not satisfied with the submitted thesis. I know there are SO MANY shortcomings of it and during my three-month viva preparation, I also constantly felt so low because of re-reading my imperfect thesis.

Here are some of the reasons that get me really worrying about not passing:
English is not my first language, so I spent so much time just to polish some very basic details.

My supervisor is not an expert in my area, so all he can help is the reasoning, logical thinking part of the thesis. Both examiners are absolute experts of my area, who may pick up some obvious things that my supervisor cannot notice.

Throughout my 4-year-plus-3-month PhD journey, I am also a freelance journalist writing for various magazines/newspapers from my home country, and have spent quite some time working on these articles as well. Although I registered as a full-time PhD student, the reality is I kind of like a part-time student.

advice for preparing viva?
V

Thank you everyone !!!! I've PASSED with minor corrections :))))
The viva only lasted for an hour, they are satisfied with my answers and freed me very soon :D
Never thought I can reach this far!!! Honestly I still think my thesis is not good enough but I am glad the examiners think it is good enough for a PhD!!!

:D (yeah~~~~)

advice for preparing viva?
V

Quote From ailicec:
Good luck for Monday :)

Thank you!!!I'm quite nervous now but try to stay positive, going to sleep soon! Viva is in the afternoon but I will go to the university early to re-read my thesis and meet my supervisor.

Good luck to myself :)))

advice for preparing viva?
V

Quote From Mog:
Hi Vivicov,
I passed with minor corrections which I've now submitted, so all is good!
I really hope Monday goes well; it is an enjoyable experience once the initial nerves have settled, since it really is your chance to talk about what you know best with people who are genuinely interested & want the best for you.
Good luck! And I look forward to checking in to see how you got on.
Very best wishes, Mog

thats great news Mog! Well done :D
I will update the result here :)) thank you again for your kind encouragement ~~

advice for preparing viva?
V

Dear Mog
Thank you so much! Have you had your viva? Hope all is well with you !
There is a music festival close to my place, although I do not go, but the atmosphere (I can hear the music hahahha!) certainly helps to make me feel like I do enjoy the sunshine over the weekend!

advice for preparing viva?
V

Quote From Vicmath:
Hi everyone! some amazing advice on here i wish i had a while ago. my viva is due in three weeks, i am absolutely stressed about it. my phd experience has been terrible, i had almost zero guidance from my first supervisor, who is very intelligent but never speaks clearly. when i started my phd she told me to read some papaers and books, and when i went to ask her questions she just blabbered on about incoherent math. she did not guide me at all and towards the last two months of my submission kept telling me that i needed another few months but i cant afford to take the time. my second supervisor was never around for the three and a bit years, although he is much more understandable, he said i have done more work than his recent phd students and that he is absolutely confident that i will pass. i already found many mistakes in my thesis after submitting, only english mistakes, but im really worried. i have two supervisors who contradict eachother and i have felt misguided by them.if anyone else has had a similar experience please let me know, and good luck to all the phd candidates here.

vic


Hi Vic
I've heard many people said that if you spot errors in your thesis after submission, do not worry, it is only NORMAL to have some, especially they are only English mistakes. What the examiners really care is the content, not how great a proofreader you are.

And if your second supervisor has so much confidence in you, you should have more in yourself as well!!! My supervisors are very supportive and kind to me, yet no one has ever said something like what your second supervisor has told you....(which implies that you work much harder than most of the PhD students under his supervision)... you should be proud of your hard work and trust yourself that you have done what you can.

advice for preparing viva?
V

Hi Dgold

Thank you! Your suggestions are great! I will keep them in mind. I've seen your thread before you mentioned it actually! Well done :)

advice for preparing viva?
V

thanks for everyone's suggestions, this is the final weekend, I cant wait to get it done!

Thank you PhD Forum
V

Quote From ailicec:
Hello all...just a short message of thanks to all on the PhD forum. I have used it on and off throughout my PhD experience and especially in the beginning stages got some invaluable advice :). Anyways I had my PhD viva yesterday and it all went well :) Have some minor corrections to do but it should be OK. Thanks to everyone :) I can give more details on the viva experience if you think it might help you.


Good Job! Mine is only few days away! Hope I can make the same post as yours soon :)

advice for preparing viva?
V

Quote From ailicec:
Quote From vivicov:
Wow I consider my department/university as very efficient? I submitted my thesis on 26th March, they sent me an email saying thesis are in examiners' hands and viva date is agreed this morning. The viva date will be 8th July !! Now I can plan things better. :)
Good luck with your viva...I submitted 3 weeks ago and mine is on the 2nd July...it all seems to be going too quickly but I am glad to see someone who is going through similar things as me :)


So you are having your viva earlier than I do! Good Luck! Hope to know the good news soon from you :)